Trade Dwight Howard for Tim Duncan?

[FkLA]

You guys are homer knuckleheads.

Of course you'd trade Duncan for Howard. The Magic are le contenders because of Howard even if it isn't obvious to you. Do you honestly think a team featuring Hedo Turkoglu and Rashard Lewis would be a finals contender without Howard?

Howard is the best young center in the game and he'll be contending for championships for the next decade.

Duncan on the other hand, while still great, is struggling to stay healthy. He can't have many years left.

Youre an idiot.

Its a thing called loyalty. Timmy stayed with us when he couldve went to Orlando to play alongside Grant Hil. He made us relevant in the NBA, he got us four les. He has taken pay cuts to help out the team financially.

Now explain to me why the we would trade him? I dont give a if the Cavs call and tell us theyll trade LeBron for Duncan, my response will be ' you'. Click. This man deserves to retire a Spur, and have a statue of him made at the entrance of the AT&T Center.

[Spursone]

Please put down your pipe before starting a new thread!

[cheney212]

this question doesnt deserve to even be posted dwight will never be near duncan even when duncans in a casket

[spursjustice]

I wouldn't even think about it. Howard is an awesome talent but what Timmy has brought to the Spurs in the past decade will never be forgotten. Furthermore, his tank isn't empty yet. Nonetheless, out of respect & loyalty, I wouldn't even consider a trade.

[FuzzyLumpkins]

I wonder what Howard's game will be like when he is 34? Will he even be in the league at 34?

Its more like I wonder what Howards production will be when hes 27 and in his prime and Duncan's retired.

[SonOfAGun]

If Duncan had Howard's physique he would have been the greatest of all humans to ever play basketball.

[Bukefal]

What a stupid thread. no one would ever trade timmy.

[LEONARD]

So it appears that most would not be for this trade right now??

[4RINGS]

You guys are homer knuckleheads.

Of course you'd trade Duncan for Howard. The Magic are le contenders because of Howard even if it isn't obvious to you. Do you honestly think a team featuring Hedo Turkoglu and Rashard Lewis would be a finals contender without Howard?

Howard is the best young center in the game and he'll be contending for championships for the next decade.

Duncan on the other hand, while still great, is struggling to stay healthy. He can't have many years left.

Trade Dirk for Howard, that is an even trade... neither guy is a WINNER!!

[LEONARD]

Gortat and Lewis for Duncan maybe??

[Chieflion]

Gortat and Lewis for Duncan maybe??

Spurstalk has reached a new low.

[ElNono]

Bonner for Howard's used sneakers...

[dbreiden83080]

Hypothetical...based on talent and where they are in their careers right now (ie, ignore money)...

Would you be mad if the Spurs traded Duncan for Howard???

Fedor for BJ Penn Straight up..

[bishopospurs]

Duncan is still>>>>>Howard

[poeticism707]

Duncan is still>>>>>Howard

[Jose Ole]

I would trade Finley for a box of Froot Loops and Bonner for a case of Bacon Bits.

[Muser]

I would trade Finley for a box of Froot Loops and Bonner for a case of Bacon Bits.

We might have to send some first rounders to get that done.

[Evan]

Duncan is still>>>>>Howard

How so? Explain please.

[Evan]

What a stupid thread. no one would ever trade timmy.

you can't totally write it off tho

[ffadicted]

If Duncan had Howard's physique he would have been the greatest of all humans to ever play basketball.

If Allen Iverson had Lebron James' physique, he'd probably still be making max contracts and having a couple of rings.

If Matt Bonner had Howard's physique, he would probably be an all star.

If Duncan was 8 inches smaller, he probably wouldn't be an NBA Player.

Should I go on

[4RINGS]

you can't totally write it off tho

Dirk is the guy who should be dealt. That is when the Mavs will be able to start to built a real team. A defensive minded team, until then the Mavs will just be second rate.

[FkLA]

How so? Explain please.

Howard's offensive game is way too raw, even as beat-up and worn down as Timmy is his offensive game is still miles ahead of Howard's...all he does is rely on his athleticism and the fact that he's bigger than alot of players. Timmy has the whole package. Howard may get the nod on the defensive end, but Duncan is no slouch on that end...even at his age he is still one of the best defenders and rebounders in the league.

Give me Timmy over Howard right now. A couple a years Howard will be better, but even at his peak Howard will not come close to the player Duncan was in 02-03 when he won back2back MVPs.

[LEONARD]

Howard's offensive game is way too raw, even as beat-up and worn down as Timmy is his offensive game is still miles ahead of Howard's...all he does is rely on his athleticism and the fact that he's bigger than alot of players. Timmy has the whole package. Howard may get the nod on the defensive end, but Duncan is no slouch on that end...even at his age he is still one of the best defenders and rebounders in the league.

Give me Timmy over Howard right now. A couple a years Howard will be better, but even at his peak Howard will not come close to the player Duncan was in 02-03 when he won back2back MVPs.

Not a bad breakdown actually...

hmmmmmm

Still debating this one though...

[TDMVPDPOY]

How so? Explain please.

[LEONARD]

When in doubt, reply with 4 Rings...