sons IF Mavs win le this year Dirk will surpass Duncan as best PF of last 15 years

[SpurOutofTownFan]

I'm sorry son but I can't follow you where you are going

You cannot compare Duncan to Dirk - for multiple reasons, the least how many points they have both scored

[DMC]

If the Heat win, Lebron is better than Jordan.

[TE]

Dirk has been better than Duncan the past couple of years. But in accounting for entire careers, Duncan has done much more. Championships, MVP's, no consistent chokes while in his prime.


This is a good argument though. But overall, I would take a prime Duncan over a prime Nowitski. That's how you have to evaluate it.


oh, and David West sucks and will never be as good as a prime Duncan/Dirk. tee, hee.

[mystargtr34]

Tbh if Dirk rings this year it's comparable to what Duncan did with the 2003 Spurs .. no other legitimate "star" help .. only Duncan in 2003 and Hakeem in 95 have lead their team to a ring with strictly role players in the modern era.. unless u count Kobe as a role player in 00 where he shot 35% against te Pacers in the finals..then u can add Shaq to the list.

What Dirk is doing is ridiculous

[100%duncan]

4>1? do the math you mutha a

[xellos88330]

What I find odd is that you discredit the ring count as a proof of superiority, yet in your thread le, you require Dirk to get a ring in order to surpass Duncan.

You need to take a trolling class.

[Sean Cagney]

Lmfao hahahahahaha okay.

[Sean Cagney]

Dirk > DuncanPERIOD

Another F IN IDIOT IN HERE AT TIMES! LOL.

[DMC]

Another F IN IDIOT IN HERE AT TIMES! LOL.

Dirk has been better than Tim for at least a couple of years now. It's no secret.

[DJ Mbenga]

i see ma br has made some new friends with some spurs fans

[Sean Cagney]

Parker has three rings so he surpasses Paul as the best PG int he last ten years....... Okay if you want to do that bro!

Finals MVP >>>>>>>>> NEAR MVP! YEP. YES SONS@!!!!!!!!!

[werewolf]

Boy am I sick of this . Look at Dirk's play-off stats will you? Are those the stats of a choker? Maybe, just maybe it was the rest of the team? Duncan is an all-time great. So is Dirk. Leave it alone.

[endrity]

Take your pick of sources, just show me one that shows Dirk over Tim other than the OP. Slam Magazine's "new top 50" lists Tim 8th all time, with Kobe at 12. Dirk isn't in the top 50. That was in 2009. What's really changed since then?

Tim's team ousted Dirk's in the 1st round last year.

Than Slam has a real problem, if a guy with an MVP, two other top 3 finishes, and 4 All-NBA First team can't get in their top 50.

If he wins a ring, Dirk settles somewhere in the top 20.

[Halberto]

- Dirk can take over games, Duncan never could

- Duncan is the far better rebounder, Dirk's rebounding is only average considering his size

- Dirk is the far better scorer, Duncan hasn't been a scoring threat in years

- Both are relatively even on defense, Duncan's defense has always been overrated

- Dirk is a more accurate shooter from all over the court, Duncan has a better post game

- Dirk is the better performer in the playoffs

- Dirk has had to carry the Mavs most of his career, Duncan has always had solid teams

good job

[ManuBalboa]

BR....c'mon son. This is just weak.

[leemajors]

tbh David West is the greatest PF in the game sons, just bad luck kept the hornets out of the second round

[Cry Havoc]

Gnsf

[D-Wade #3]

BRHornet is right sons

[ATXSPUR]

[WeNeedLength]

lol thread.

[Bill_Brasky]

son IF this thread reaches 8 pages BRhornet will surpass Koolaid_Man as most successful troll of the past 5 years.

[Greg Oden]

BR already takes a wet on koolaid man already in that regard, tbh.

[Sigz]

Duncan could never take over games?


LOL get tha outta here

[TampaDude]

The only stat that matters is 4 rings>0 rings. Dirk is better right now, but not over the last 15 years

^ this

Even if/when Dirk rings this June, it's still gonna be 4 > 1.

[dbreiden83080]

Dirk can take over games, Duncan never could

Stopped reading here..