The fact is, this team needs to get more athletic.
Duncan is no longer great enough to win soley on his own. You guys can love Tony Parker all you want, and I'm a fan of his too, but if you can increase their chances to win now, then you take that chance when you can. Remember when so many of you were so bent on keeping Brown over Finley? What happened there?
If you can aquire an all-star, you take it. Parker is a great player, but if you can find a player that while might be older, you get someone who can help you win now, and have them be your main core with athletic young guys off the bench or at other positions in the rotation, like JR Smith, and whoever else they can pick up.
Besides, I said Randolph was all-star LEVEL, meaning he has talent to bring it and put up numbers to get there. Pair him with Duncan and you have a monster low post set that can hit outside shots.