I'll have to find the thread but I believe Mr. Majors is misrepresenting my position on Van Hagar from years ago. I believe what I said was that Van Halen's music in the Hagar years (a) is underappreciated, and (b) at times had more depth and range. The Hagar years were superior lyrically and I think that group was able to better pull off the mid-tempo songs and the ballads.
Anyway, my position now is that if you're locking me up for the rest of my life and I can only take one or the other, I'm taking the DLR albums. The guitar work is better, the albums are more consistently good all the way through and the style is just more fun overall.