Reply With Quote
i haven't seen it in awhile.
It's sucking ASS tonight!!
i haven't seen it in awhile.
Elliot.. ouch!
Me =
I can honestly say that all of them sucked equally tonight. :vomit
why aren't you there?
I actually love that original version of that song and probably listen to it about every day. I wasn't a fan of Mandisas version tonight though.
Chris shouted the whole time. Blech.
Katharine was great as usual.
Lisa will probably go home after that performance. She's nowhere near as good as Kelly.
Angel, I agree with the comment about Taylors face. He is a good looking man.
Ace was the best of the night :eek
Elliot was great, but, that dancing, WTF was that?!!?
Kelly Pickler wasn't bad, of course, singing a country song in front of all the pop people is just horrible so they HAD to shoot her down.
Lisa was fantastic!
Mandisa's worst performance.
Bucky's BEST, didn't hurt that it was one of my favorite songs from Tim Mcgraw
Paris's performance was good, but Simon was right, it sounded like a kid trying to be like Beyonce.
all in all prob the worst show so far
Yeah he took that song too harsh.Chris shouted the whole time. Blech.
The original, if sang just a tick softer, is one of a rock song.
Of course my parents who I watched it with thought it was reprehensible.
I thought it was decent.
But not Chris's best.
No, it was a "Grandma Got Run Over By a Reindeer" song ... those kinds of songs make country look stupid.Kelly Pickler wasn't bad, of course, singing a country song in front of all the pop people is just horrible so they HAD to shoot her down.
Bucky was actually decent this time...but not really good
Lisa was terrible ... I was constantly comparing it to Kelly Clarkson and it was like 165465132465 X worse. It'd be like choosing a Celine Dion or Mariah Carey song ... you have to be flawless to even appear decent.
I have to go back and watch Elliott .... I was watching Dallas v. Detroit and missed it.
I am, you didn't know that?
it was not.No, it was a "Grandma Got Run Over By a Reindeer" song
Its a spunky love song.
Grandma got run over by a reindeer come on.
Mandisa sucks.
Seriously...it was a goofy song. Suds in a Bucket or whatever? Come on.
Just like Chris' was ...
remember what i said about Chris last week.
Why I thought he didn't do that great of a job had nothing to do with his style, I just didn't like the way he did that particular song. Because unlike pretty much everyone in the history of everyone, I happen to actually really like Creed.
I'm right there with you Spurswoman! As for my man Chris, was not his best, but still loved it! What kills me though is Simon completly doing a 360 this week. Last week it was congrats for being you and not compromising, this week it is you can't just keep being you and win this? I don't get that?
Yeah...that was a little odd.
Anyone know where I can view the latest Idol performances online? 'cause over here we get them a week or two late I think and I missed the last one.
You obviously didn't hear all the lyrics.Seriously...it was a goofy song. Suds in a Bucket or whatever? Come on
its about a girl eloping with her bf to get married, and the town being in shock that such a good girl would do such a thing.
Sara Evans sang it, but of course, shes fifty times the singer Kelly Pickler is.
I think Suds is one of those songs you either love or hate.
Last night's performances pretty much sucked a lot of ass.
WTF? There is nothing wrong with my hearing. For a singing compe ion, that was a stupid song to pick.
Not your HEARING.
You didnt hear the WHOLE song.
Settle down now....
Its a fun song to sing, and Im sure thats why she sang it.
So is Grandma Got Run Over By a Reindeer.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
