Try it out man. It reminds me so much of Skyrim with how much there is to discover and how many awesome dungeons there are. But unlike Skyrim, of course it has first rate combat being a FromSoft game. Doesn't have Skyrim's ridiculous soundtrack and the story is as bare bones as can be, but I can't ing put the controller down once I get started in this. Feels like the game will have same kind of replay value as Skyrim too given how differently you can play the game. Right now I'm playing a dexterity build using a sword with bleed and a monster special attack with no shield, but seeing all the crazy magic you can do in this game makes me want to do another intelligence based build later on like how I went through Skyrim first as the default all around nord character, second playthrough a khajit sneak thief / assassin, third playthrough a mage, etc. I won't say 10/10 since I'm still early in the game and it really takes something to make a game 10/10 in my book, but it's at least a 9.5/10 for me. To get it to 10/10 in my book I would need to see at least one boss fight as good as Orphan of Kos in Bloodborne though most likely. And they might be saving that for a DLC.
I haven't played Dark Souls 3 yet so I can't tell you how different the Elden Ring battle system is from it. Pretty different from Dark Souls 1 and Bloodborne though. Although there is a rune you can equip to bring back the Bloodborne rally system where you get health back for counterattacking after being hit.