Reply With Quote
Now you tie male to man. So you support cisgender policies?
When the man decides hes a woman do those advantages no longer matter?
To what extent should they be? I’d rather ask medical professionals
Now you tie male to man. So you support cisgender policies?
When the man decides hes a woman do those advantages no longer matter?
im saying the micro percentage exists.
Ive read some interesting opinions on how you can actually accommodate, such as:
trans women must compete with men until they have undergone at least 12 consecutive months of hormone therapy, at which point they must compete with women
trans men have the option of competing with either until they have undergone at least 12 consecutive months... at which point they can only compete with men.
I don’t mind having similar standards on a sport by sport basis. We are just just talking about schools here.
They don’t. It’s technically incorrect but i don’t think it’s harmful enough to worry about, and given our understanding of the numbers it’s pretty damn reasonable to assume the kid is cis gendered until further noticeDo you think doctors say congrats its a male?
Its not a medical issue. Its an ethics issue. Would you let a boy who claims to be a girl sleep with your daughter?
People don’t just up and decide. I also recognize that the biology doesn’t disappear. see my post above
Do parents typically consent to their kids sex choices?
the degree to which somebody is psychologically harmed is a medical question. The degree to which hormone therapy can offset previous differences is inherently medical
Whats reasonable changes when you get skin in the game. Assuming cisgender as normal is the new racism.
I didnt mention sex. Daughter is 12. Boy/girl is 13.
The fearmongering scenario of dude suddenely deciding I’m a girl is absurd.
Certainly a school would be able to inquire about the child’s history. Have they seen psychologists? Have they been presenting themselves as being of the particular gender for any significant period of time? Are the undergoing hormone therapy or on puberty blockers, etc
You said sleep with, which is often a euphemism for sex.
If you are referring to a sleepover situation for kids, see my previous post
I self identify as African American and I support President Trump
Don’t think there’s any significant psychologic or medical backing for a condition of trans-racial identification but sure, go along with your strawman
What if I told you I'm a trans
Id say the same exact thing as my previous post but also call you a probable racist
Are you really being serious? Even top women tennis players can be beaten by some high school/college male players. I suspect your tune might change if ever a daughter of yours competes/tries her very best and gets nowhere against males - especially where scholarship/prize money is concerned.
Last edited by rmt; 08-13-2020 at 06:46 AM.
Source: Madeupmonkey .com
plus, if you want to be a trans MTF and play basketball, your American salary in the WNBA is less than a corporate level programmer. Need to move to the USSR to make the big bucks.
Can you identify as trans racial (on a census or otherwise) if your wife/kids are a different race than you? Even if you don't take those melanin shots, lol.
Lite's sperm shielding in this thread off the charts.
total bull , same myth around military service.
Neither is guaranteed, or even probable, to "build (male) character" which usually means MachoMan "toxic masculinity" devoid of morals, ethics, fair play, respect for others.
This kind of stuff is where Dems need to drop it (assuming the OP is actually true). Most Kids grow up without going to an all girls or all boys school, I don’t see why trannies having to do the same is such a big deal.
As for sports, sorry but it’s not fair to girls if they have to compete against a 6’3” 250 lbs. behemoth even if the person is legit trans. There are plenty of people with disabilities who can’t participate in sports at all, it’s not some grave injustice if trans people (a tiny portion of the population) are in the same boat.
"University of Montana runner June Eastwood, a biologically male athlete who identifies as a transgender woman, was named the Big Sky Conference’s female athlete of the week in October 2019."
any relation?
So, are they gonna shrink x (average difference between men and women) inches and weigh x pounds less after 12 consecutive months of this hormone therapy?
OMGosh - all my good thoughts of Dirty Harry just became like thoughts of Bruce Jenner winning the decathalon."University of Montana runner June Eastwood, a biologically male athlete who identifies as a transgender woman, was named the Big Sky Conference’s female athlete of the week in October 2019."
any relation?
How many 6’3 250 pound trans college athletes are there?
This isn’t remotely the most important issue to me (I’ve already told you what i think priority issues for the election should be, and the two biggest issues for me personally besides those are climate change and healthcare)... but the fearmongering over Lebron just up and deciding he’s a girl so he can dominate girls basketball in junior high is made up
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
