I know how the German system works, and it doesn't work like that, period. Not saying 101A is lying, just probably didn't get the right info. I know 101A is a standup person.
And other countries might be worse than the US... all I said is that there's plenty of examples of countries where College is free, not even admission tests and it works pretty well, including a secondary market for private, paid schools.
Uh, no, that's actually not true, but you're not well versed enough in economics to understand why that's not true. The question actually is much different, and it has to do with what do the people of the given country feel the role of the state should be in certain areas. That obviously varies from country to country, but taking the German example, they feel the state should provide education and health for it's citizens. What's even more interesting/extreme with Germany is that College is free even for foreigners. It's not uncommon for Americans to get a free College education in Germany.