Jackson just had an MVP season. I'm not sure Jimmy is top ten even.
Jimmy is superior to Jackson and I wouldn't put my guy Top 5
Jackson just had an MVP season. I'm not sure Jimmy is top ten even.
So? The majority GOAT was selected 200.
Yes Jackson had a monster season stat padding against Browns, Bengals, Dolphins, Jets (16 TDs)
No way I prefer Jackson under center on Saturday in a must win game, over Jimmy
he led the NFL in touchdown passes with 36 despite only playing 15 games. he separately had another 7 rushing touchdowns. even if you take away those top 4 games you mentioned (which is a stupid thing to do), that is still 20 touchdown passes in 11 games, which puts him on pace for 29 in a full season. spoiler alert: thats more than jimmy had
i'll also wait for you to let us know jimmys games against cardinals and bengals (11 touchdowns in 3 games) dont count either
yeah beacuse one is black and one is white. nothing to do with how good they areNo way I prefer Jackson under center on Saturday in a must win game, over Jimmy
They are a corpse pretty much.
Compare Jimmy's performance in his teams biggest games (especially on the Road) to Jackson.
I'm seeing 2 total passing TDs for Jackson in 4 games - Patriots, Chiefs, Seahawks & 49ers. 2 games with 70.6 and below passer rating.
Great player against the doormats of the NFL. Average player against playoff compe ion.
Jimmy 7 passing TDs in 49ers four biggest games.
Either way, Mahomes, Rodgers, Jackson (and Brees) were top of the class.
This year, Jimmy G was back there with Dak and Cousins.
Why would you take out Jackson's rushing stats out of the equation?
jackson was dominant in the biggest game against the pats. he only threw 1 passing TD but he was unstoppable all game. its a very archaic way to just look at TD passes
I like CN, but his posting in the NFL forum is all schtick you'll barely find Packers fans that rate Rodgers highly after the worst season of his career.
Ranking QBs is essentially ranking the best scheme and supporting cast, tbh. There are exceptions, of course(the elite of the elite all-time), but the only current elite QB that isn't aided by a scheme is Wilson. Even Mahomes, as great as he is, has a loaded team with a scheme that has made every previous QB in it look good, even the bad ones.
Kyle Shanahan makes every QB look good, as well, there's a reason Belichick wanted Jimmy G to go there
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)