PDA

View Full Version : Why Cleveland would be dumb to get Amare



DUNCANownsKOBE2
01-24-2009, 03:58 PM
In the other thread several other people mentioned Cleveland trading for Amare and they would be incredibly dumb to do that. Amare would obviously spend all his time at power forward and not center. He has shown that he is a lot more limited offensively as a 4 as oppose to a 5, and his defense still sucks. More importantly, look at the Suns decision making process in recent years:

2006-2007 season: After a controversial exit from the playoffs Amare has his annual late May early June press conference about how much he wants to get better and how much better his defense will be the next year.
They trade James Jones who became useless once Amare came back. The only free agent seasoned and smart enough to play with Amare signs with the Suns (Grant Hill). A relatively unproductive off season because Sarver is convinced Amare getting suspended was not Amare's wrong doing, it was bad luck, and with the new and improved Amare the Suns could dump KT's interior defense for nothing and it would be fine. He hires a puppet GM who won't have the balls to disagree.

2007-2008 season: After much pressure from Kerr and Sarver D'antoni runs the offense through Amare. Similar to Amare, they dominate the weaker competition, suck against better teams, and look a lot better than they really are because of an easy 1st half schedule. Still, the dumping of KT made their interior D so bad even Kerr spoke up about it.
Since Marion clearly didn't get along with prince Amare, Sarver was convinced Marion was the newest reason why Amare wasn't scoring 40 PPG while playing hall of fame defense and Amare would dominate once he was moved to power forward without having to deal with Marion being a cancer. This led to trading for Shaq and throwing Marion under the bus even after all he had done for the Suns.
They falter after the Shaq trade because the media made everyone forget about all that Marion did at the time of the Marion trade. Just like the 2007 season, Diaw, Raja, Hill and Barbosa all become increasingly inconsistent down the stretch once the ball is forced into Amare more and more.
And even more like the 2007 season, Amare has a monster series against San Antonio statistically but all of those stats came in the 1st half of games and several dumb errors made by Amare late in game 1 and 2 caused a loss.
More to the point, there is a new scapegoat as to why Amare didn't carry the Suns to a title, D'antoni. The media led a campaign to drive D'antoni out of town because he didn't get Amare the ball enough in the playoffs, even though they were best in the playoffs when they went to Diaw . Amare bought into this and threw the coach that turned him into an elite scorer under the bus saying he wants to be the go to guy and D'antoni is too stubborn to make him the go to guy.
Surprised that D'antoni isn't the only person in the world who thinks Amare isn't a franchise player, Kerr eventually stumbles upon Terry Porter, a notorious yes man who Kerr could boss around.
For the 3rd straight year, there is little to no off season improvement because everyone is under the impression Amare will take his game to the next level and he'll put the Suns on his back. In addition, D'antoni has become the root of every problem the Suns ever had and Porter will use the bench full of unused talent, turn them into the defensive team they're capable of being, and finally get Amare to reach his potential.

2008-2009 season: Turning Amare into a half court scorer and a great defensive player isn't as easy as Kerr and Porter said it would be. In the process of trying to turn Amare into Tim Duncan, they turn the ball over at a ridiculous rate trying to force it into someone who had absolutely no idea how to get open in the post. They also kill the confidence of both rookies who were supposed to be good and further shorten the bench because only a few players are able to be remotely productive playing with Amare. No worries, they just need a good 2-guard to free Amare up. They trade two players disgruntled with playing for a team where Amare has more power than the coach.
The two players no longer playing with Amare immediately start playing up to their potential, J-Rich immediately losses confidence and becomes way less productive. Now Porter is being blamed for killing Amare's confidence and that D'antoni should come back, even though Porter was supposed to be to Amare what Popovich is to Duncan. Shaq is somehow being blamed for Amare's struggles because he's a "ball hog" and he takes Amare out of the offense even though Amare received no blame when he made Diaw useless.




Now people are starting to figure out that MAYBE Amare is the one with the problem rather than Stern, Marion, D'antoni, Diaw, Bell, Porter, and Shaq. Cleveland doesn't want this bum.

Kobe™
01-24-2009, 04:38 PM
lulz.

TheNextGen
01-24-2009, 05:08 PM
omg..i want to read that whole post but it seems like it might take me an hour.

lil_penny
01-24-2009, 05:10 PM
Amare had me fooled... I've been noticing how much of a lazy bums he is as of late. All I can say is thanks god I didn't get him on my fantasy league haha

DUNCANownsKOBE2
01-24-2009, 05:39 PM
Amare had me fooled... I've been noticing how much of a lazy bums he is as of late. All I can say is thanks god I didn't get him on my fantasy league haha

He is still decent in that area, keep in mind you don't need to play good defense to be a good fantasy player. You just need to gamble a lot by going for blocks and steals, even if it makes you a worse defender. That's what Amare considers good D.

Chief
01-24-2009, 05:39 PM
Excellent Post.

Very informative and well put together.

I think Lebron has to be surrounded with Players that don't have an ego. It's hard to find guy's like that but that's what it's going to take. Lebron is the man in Cleveland, Him and Amare could never possibly co-exist.

IronMexican
01-24-2009, 05:44 PM
lulz.

Ace, who is that on the avy?

Kobe™
01-24-2009, 05:55 PM
Me .

edit:
Whose Ace.?

IronMexican
01-24-2009, 05:58 PM
Me .

edit:
Whose Ace.?

Lol, you're stupid. Anyways, I do this trade if I'm Cle

Kobe™
01-24-2009, 06:00 PM
lol .

DUNCANownsKOBE2
01-24-2009, 06:10 PM
Lol, you're stupid. Anyways, I do this trade if I'm Cle

We'll in all likelihood never know how it would work but I guarantee it wouldn't work. There is only 1 basket to be scored on every possession, unless Amare is the player making the shot someone else create he does nothing for a team on offense. He doesn't open up the floor with his presence, he doesn't move well with or without the ball, and he only goes for offensive rebounds when he missed his own layup. He can't pass out of double teams either.

And also, did you forgot the Cavs are built on defense. Good luck keeping that identity after Amare is in town.

pauls931
01-24-2009, 06:21 PM
I think it could possibly work short term, but would be destined for a Shaq/Kobe breakup.

Thunder Dan
01-24-2009, 07:31 PM
I think Danny Ferry will do what he thinks is best for the Cavs. I mean the guy traded Larry Hughes and Drew Gooden to the Bulls (who thought they fleeced the Cavs, but now they are trying to get rid of Hughes) for Wallace, Wally, Joe Smith and Delonte West. I mean that is a steal for the Cavs when you look at how good Wallace and West are playing, but their flexability with Wally's contract. He picked JJ Hickson with the 17th pick, who looks like he is going to be a very good player.....and the best move is he got Mo Williams for Joe Smith and Damon Jones.

It's hard to knock Ferry for any of his moves after his first season when he signed Donyell Marshall, Hughes and Damon Jones. He finally knows the team they want, and the players they need. Mo Williams never played defense, but he does now. Maybe Amare will change, but who knows- it's all up to Ferry

DUNCANownsKOBE2
01-25-2009, 02:44 AM
Mo Williams never played defense, but he does now. Maybe Amare will change, but who knows- it's all up to Ferry

Mo Williams was ripped by the Milwaukee media and fans for not playing defense and hogging the ball too much, that taught him a lesson.

When Amare doesn't play defense, the Phoenix media and fans decide to blame other players and the coach for not holding Amare's hand and making defense as easy as possible for him.

When he hogs the ball too much, the fans and media criticize the other players for not playing hard and inexplicably presume it's not Amare's fault at all that he can't get his teammates involved.

The fans, owner, media, etc. have sent Amare the message he can do no wrong and it will never be his fault, unfortunately he has bought into that and his attitude reflects it.

Bob Lanier
01-25-2009, 04:29 AM
I think it could possibly work short term, but would be destined for a Shaq/Kobe breakup.
Why's that? Àmäré's even more of a divo than Kobe, but James is much more media-correct and less like a third grader on meth than Shaq.

If he went to Cleveland, Stoudemire would quickly learn to decide between jelly and syrup.

Austin_Toros
01-25-2009, 05:01 AM
i dunno.
i think amare MAY help cleveled. but who knows

Austin_Toros
01-25-2009, 05:45 AM
Since Marion clearly didn't get along with prince Amare, Sarver was convinced Marion was the newest reason why Amare wasn't scoring 40 PPG while playing hall of fame defense and Amare would dominate once he was moved to power forward without having to deal with Marion being a cancer. This led to trading for Shaq and throwing Marion under the bus even after all he had done for the Suns.
And even more like the 2007 season, Amare has a monster series against San Antonio statistically but all of those stats came in the 1st half of games and several dumb errors made by Amare late in game 1 and 2 caused a loss.
2008-2009 season: Turning Amare into a half court scorer and a great defensive player isn't as easy as Kerr and Porter said it would be. In the process of trying to turn Amare into Tim Duncan, they turn the ball over at a ridiculous rate trying to force it into someone who had absolutely no idea how to get open in the post.
The two players no longer playing with Amare immediately start playing up to their potential, J-Rich immediately losses confidence and becomes way less productive. Shaq is somehow being blamed for Amare's struggles because he's a "ball hog" and he takes Amare out of the offense even though Amare received no blame when he made Diaw useless.


Amare "all he can do is dunk" Stoudemire is not the player he used to be. His knee injuries have slowed him, but also the Suns slower style of play. More importantly, I think the Suns have committed suicide as they have brought all this shit on themselves.

Amare scorin 40 ppg isn't going to happen- although it nearly did at one stage!
He did an AMAZING series against san antonio.
BUT he needs Nash in order to function and the cull of the Suns run 'n gun game has destroyed Stoudemire and the rest of the team!

Now the issue of the Suns role players- this is where Phoenix really F up. They traded Diaw and Bell who where very solid players but where being used less and less. Diaw was fantastic when Amare was out injured and had achieved many triple doubles. Its also a shame that Barbosa wasn't respected enough. Anyway, trading Diaw and Bell has finally showed everybody how good these players are- just looks at them now in Charlotte.

So yes, the suns have screwed themselves and they are now screwing over J-Rich.

:lmao

m33p0
01-25-2009, 09:41 AM
i'd rather have david lee than be burdened with amare.

DUNCANownsKOBE2
01-25-2009, 04:55 PM
Amare "all he can do is dunk" Stoudemire is not the player he used to be. His knee injuries have slowed him, but also the Suns slower style of play. More importantly, I think the Suns have committed suicide as they have brought all this shit on themselves.

Amare scorin 40 ppg isn't going to happen- although it nearly did at one stage!
He did an AMAZING series against san antonio.
BUT he needs Nash in order to function and the cull of the Suns run 'n gun game has destroyed Stoudemire and the rest of the team!

Now the issue of the Suns role players- this is where Phoenix really F up. They traded Diaw and Bell who where very solid players but where being used less and less. Diaw was fantastic when Amare was out injured and had achieved many triple doubles. Its also a shame that Barbosa wasn't respected enough. Anyway, trading Diaw and Bell has finally showed everybody how good these players are- just looks at them now in Charlotte.

So yes, the suns have screwed themselves and they are now screwing over J-Rich.

:lmao


It was sarcasm, for years the Suns have been waiting for Amare to become an elite big man like KG and Duncan and they still are incapable of considering the possibility that Amare just isn't that good.

Rogue
01-25-2009, 09:07 PM
a related negociation may begin if the suns accept ben wallace as the leverage for amare. :lmao