Have players been overhyped before and amounted to nothing? Yes.
On the flip side, there are players sometimes people can spot a mile away and predict they become a star. You insist so much that since you read a few scouting reports that said he didn’t have a ceiling as a star that it must be unlikely for it to actually happen. There were several scouting reports out there that you ignored that did say he would become one, so why must it be that the few you read be the accurate ones?
Not every prospect ever has to have a label on them “THIS PLAYER WILL LIKELY BE A STAR” for people to comment on them the way they are doing with Castle. Sometimes you can see it in the way they move on the court. You separate out the fandom in watching a guy play and one with a good eye can spot the talent there. It’s not all about numbers, no wing or guard will ever become as efficient as Kawhi was.
Hypothetically if Castle was trending to become a true star in these coming years, I already know it will take you until the very last year, month, week, or day before he’s officially announced as a star by mainstream media to acknowledge that he is one. That’s what happened with Murray at least— a player who, while not really a true star in this league, reached a ceiling you never thought would happen as evidence by your numerous posts that said he didn’t have the adequate tools and there was nothing in scouting reports that indicated he would be anything close to what he eventually became. Sound familiar?