What would interest me is how the analytics looked for last year's class and compare it with how the players did in their rookie years.
I do wonder what Primo would have amounted to if he kept it in his pants. We forget now, but he was showing promising signs on offense, was a solid defender, and was being lauded for his cool/collected confidence. I’m not saying he would have being anything close to Castle, but I also remember thinking that I saw the logic of taking the big swing. And the org itself was marketing him as the next big thing too.
What would interest me is how the analytics looked for last year's class and compare it with how the players did in their rookie years.
Had to make modifications after watching more tape… Jase is ridiculously talented
Assumption: Flagg and Harper are both gone.
First choice with our pick: Kon
Then, my first choice with the Atl pick: Sorber
If Sorber’s gone, then Jase Richardson
if Jase’s gone, then Egor Demin
if Egor is gone, then CMB
… I call this the “High IQ” group and the scenario I feel is most likely to happen
Second choice with our pick: VJ Edgecombe
Then, my first choice with the Atl pick: Sorber
if Sorber’s gone, then CMB
if CMB’s gone, then Fleming
… I call this group, “Clamps”
Third choice with our pick: Jase Richardson
Then, first choice with the Atl pick: Sorber
If Sorber’s gone, then Egor Demin,
If Egor’s gone, then any of Fleming, Beringer, Carter Bryant
… I call this group “Spurs Way” because I could def see them doing something like this
Fourth choice with our pick: Sorber
Then, my first choice with the Atl pick: Fleming
if Fleming’s gone, then CMB
if CMB’s gone, then Noa Essengue
if Noa’s gone, then Yaxel Lendeborg
… I call this group, “Physicality”
Fifth choice with our pick: Derik Queen
Then, my first choice with the Atl pick: Jase Richardson
if Jase’s gone, then Egor Demin
if Egor’s gone, then Ben Saraf
if Ben’s gone, then Danny Wolf
… I call this group the “Showtime Spurs”. I view this as the most unlikely scenario.
Ex is right though. BPA in the context of the NBA draft clearly includes a level of projection, as in who's the player that we expect would develop the most. Otherwise, in the literal meaning of BPA, they'd be drafting upper classmen in the lottery instead of freshmen.
Spurs ed up in their evaluation, sure, but Primo clearly was the so called BPA to them at that point of the draft.
It’s a discussion forum. We discuss.
I can do this but I’ll keep it to top 10 and Stephon Castle
Based on Scottspurs data, Carter Bryant is valuable.
Thank you Scottspurs for your effort!
I'm not surprised teams do this kind data for the past several years and then compare to their actual performance in the NBA.
Carter Bryant looks more NBA ready than Fleming and also fits the 3-and-D wing type we are looking for. He reminds me of Risacher
Yeah, he's the sort of turn the Spurs have done historically. I would think he's more likely than a Fleming and may be on the same tier as a Bryant in terms of growth possibilities. I wouldn't be surprised at all with the second pick.
Slight point: Sengun was clearly the BPA in the draft, even if teams were passing him. His accomplishments were significant at that point. His playing type seemed to push teams off.
Primo did seem like a good kid, and he impressed with leadership at the draft combine. I can see him being a good person with a compulsion that was anti-social and very disruptive.
As for who was left, Trey Murphy and Herb Jones (iirc) were there, but Murphy had a pretty questionable year at Virginia and Jones wasn't really on anyone's radar. It wasn't a terrible swing at a very young player with size who was taking on increased duties at Alabama later in their year. It just got completely derailed by whatever was going on with him.
I don't get why Carter Bryant didn't get more run with Arizona. Signaling from coaches that he couldn't be trusted to do more than he did, when lots of freshmen were doing much more. I'm not out on him but it's big question marks.
How this Class stacks up against past classes
DRAPM- Defensive Metric
2025 2024
Thomas Sorber- 6.1 Jamal Shead- 6.0 Kam Jones- 5.0 Ryan Dunn- 4.2 Cooper Flagg- 5.0 Reed Sheppard- 4.0 Sion James- 4.4 Devin Carter- 4.0 Walter Clayton Jr.- 4.3 Kyshawn George- 3.8 Derik Queen- 4.1 Zach Edey- 3.2 Danny Wolf- 4.0 Dalton Knecht- 3.2 Kon Knueppel- 3.9 Donovan Clingdan- 3.1 Carter Bryant- 3.6 Stephon Castle- 3.1 Jase Richardson- 3.4 Kevin McCullar Jr- 2.9
2023 2022
Julian Phillips- 7.5 Tari Eason- 5.0 Adem Boma- 4.5 Chet Holmgren- 3.9 Brandon Miller- 4.3 Walker Kessler- 3.8 Jaime Jaquez- 3.6 Kennedy Chandler- 3.8 Gradey - 2.9
Anthony Black- 2.7 TyTy Washington- 3.6 Ricky Council IV- 2.6 Paolo Banchero- 3.3 Baylor Scheierman- 2.5 Christian Braun- 3.1 Tristan De Silva- 2.5 Trevor Keels- 2.8 Terrence Shannon Jr- 2.0 Christian Koloko- 2.8
Good analysis. I'd also put Jalen Johnson in there as a possible BPA w/Sengun.
I think how Primo performed in the draft scrimmages is what put him over others in Spurs eyes at the time. Also think the Spurs current team make up made them go for him vs a big like Sengun or a possible issues with Jalen knowing they probably wouldn't be getting true minutes at that time.
Good analysis. I'd also put Jalen Johnson in there as a possible BPA w/Sengun.
I think how Primo performed in the draft scrimmages is what put him over others in Spurs eyes at the time. Also think the Spurs current team make up made them go for him vs a big like Sengun or a possible issues with Jalen knowing they probably wouldn't be getting true minutes at that time.
I forgot Jalen Johnson was that year. He quit on Duke and Coach K in the middle of the college basketball season. After Kawhi, I doubt they were ever considering him.
The question on BPA vs Fit came up because somebody pointed out that the Spurs always do BPA. I disagree because they were swinging big on Primo to be someone who will be “special” and not the obvious general consensus BPA Şengün who had accomplished much more in Europe and seemed to be the safe pick, or the equivalent of BPA to me. The Spurscwas desperate on getting a replacement Franchise Player so they took a big swing. Regardless of what happened next, that was still a big swing and not conventional. That’s my question on BPA vs Fit.
How this Class stacks up against past classes
Win Shares
2025 2024 Cooper Flagg- 8.4 Zach Edey- 10.4 Ryan Kalkbrenner- 7.1 Cam Spencer- 7.9 Nique Clifford- 7.0 Tristen Newton- 7.4 Kon Knueppel- 6.9 KJ Simpson- 7.2 Yaxel Lendeborg- 6.8 Daron Holmes II- 6.9 Johni Broome- 6.8 RJ Davis- 6.7 Walter Clayton Jr- 6.6 Terrence Shannon Jr.- 6.3 Derik Queen- 5.9 Jamal Shead- 6.3 Eric Dixon- 5.8 Devin Carter- 6.0 Kam Jones- 4.8 Stephon Castle- 4.3
2023 2022 Marcus Sasser- 7.2 Keegan Murray- 8.6 Trayce Jackson-Davis- 7.1 Orlando Robinson- 7.1 Jaime Jaquez Jr- 7.1 Chet Holmgren- 6.3 Brandon Miller- 6.9 Mark Williams- 6.3 Daron Holmes II- 6.8 EJ Liddell- 6.3 Adama Sanogo- 6.7 Ochai Agbaji- 6.2 Oscar Tshiebwe- 6.6 Bennedict Mathurin- 6.2 Drew Timme- 6.5 Wendell Moore Jr- 6.2 Jarace Walker- 5.2 Paolo Banchero- 6.1 Gradey - 4.9 Christian Braun- 6.0
I can post more comparisons like this if y’all like. I think the most translatable ones have always been Rebounding. This also doesn’t factor in International prospects, G League Ignite Alums, and the Thompson Twins that played in that Academy.
He also moved around a lot, going to 4 HSs
Thank you Scottspurs for your efforts! Please post more.
Thank you!
BPA means BPA for spurs. So, Fit is part of the equation. Character is part of the Fit equation.
We all know Primo is a failure. But at that time, FO must have determined that he was the BPA.
For this draft, our BPA is different from the past years since we have officially have a big 3.
That's why I would pick the BPAs to compliment them and start competing immediately.
he was the only freshman in their rotation at all
It's very clear I said freshmen throughout the country.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)