This is almost laughable, unless the Amare you've been watching is from 2002-03 and 2003-04. The next time I see Howard take his man off the dribble from 20 feet out or pull up and hit an 18-foot jumper it will be the first time.
Your comparison of the two is an insult to both Howard's defense and rebounding and Amare's offense.
Amare is a significant loss. He's not a starter, so it isn't as significant as some other player, and Bosh could ablely fill Amare role, so in effect the latter part of your quote isn't too far off, but I'm really sick of posters holding on to Amare's "only able to dunk" past. Watch a game, will ya! It would only take one to see that Howard will likely never become the all-around offensive force Amare is.
That's not taking anything away from Howard.
Personally, I'm both disappointed and relieved. I'm very glad he's using some sense in this. He doesn't need unnecessary wear and tear on those knees. However, I was looking forward to seeing the new Amare compared to the 2004 Olympic version.