It would accomplish not killing someone who didn't deserve it. To me there's a huge difference between someone who goes and kills because the radio told him to do it or he heard voices from god than as opposed to one who kills because he's pissed, because he doesn't like another person, because his girl cheats on him, etc. A schizo doesn't have the same free will that a sociopath does, and should not pay the same penalty as what is given to one who can think for himself and still decides it's good to off someone. If this guy knew what he was doing and knew it was wrong, then by all means fry him to a crisp in the chair.
And if he ever truly understands and fully comprehends what he has done and the future that lies ahead of him...he will wish for death with all his heart.
Why exactly would you want to do that to an innocent man?
Mighty Christian of you if you ask me...
I still say there is something very sane about his supposedly insane actions for one facing the death penalty...
Giving him a knife or hatchet and seeing what else he does is the only way to truly evaluate his sanity...
So you're saying all he would want to do is kill himself? You seem to not be of the philosophy that every day above ground is a good one.
Well...he murdered his wife and child and permanently blinded himself...what would you consider a sane reaction to knowing you commited those actions?
"Ooops"?
Complete detatchment from the actions? Isn't that the basis for his insanity claims to begin with?
I mean isn't that the problem in the first place?
If I murdered my wife and child by cutting their hearts out and fully understood what I had done...I'd not only want to be dead, I'd think I deserved it. If I felt guilty of commiting the murders, and felt the full crushing burden of the guilt of murdering my wife and baby girl, two people I was supposed to be protecting, IMHO, the only possible reaction of a sane person...I'd think death was proper punishment.You seem to not be of the philosophy that every day above ground is a good one.
If I didn't feel guilty but fully understood what I did in the throes of insanity, and understood the full horror of those actions, which in itself sounds like a pretty insane and completely disassociated state of mind...I'd consider death a merciful release or else I'd be as insane as I was when I disassociated from the actions in the first place.
now thats what i call "blind justice"
It is clear you guys don't see eye to eye on this issue.
lmao. You are nothing but a pussy weed-smoking liberal .
How can you even begin to think an opinion from a tool like you could even come close to affecting me homie?I'm sure you have plenty of like-minded friends who make you feel comfortable, but the reality is you are a cancer on this generation.
Last edited by Rockhound; 01-12-2009 at 12:01 AM.
Base needs his eyes opened worse than this guy does...
As for myself...what can I say other than Justice should be blind.
Wanting death isn't very logical, unless you're of the belief there is something after life. Your agrument breaks down to something like I've done a lot of bad , might as well grab a shotgun, stick it in my mouth, and do one more.
Just based on the way drugs for schizophrenia work, I wonder how much he would be tormented. It seems like the drugs slow everything down in the brain as a way to quiet the 'voices', and put the person into a kind of trance. Not the best way to go through life, but decidedly superior to having your brain misfire and tell you to do all kinds of things that have no basis in reality, and surely better than being 6 feet in the ground.
He.
Killed.
His.
Wife.
and.
His.
Children.
Then.
Ripped.
Their.
Hearts.
Out.
Why try to go off the situation like it is convoluted?
Mental health problem or not,
He.
Killed.
His.
Wife.
and.
His.
Children.
Then.
Ripped.
Their.
Hearts.
Out.
If that is not instant death penalty....WTF is? Why should the state have to feed this er for 40 more years?
But you're right. Let's complicate it so some lawyers can make some money and the justice system can continue using that tax money.
Last edited by Rockhound; 01-12-2009 at 12:03 AM.
Either that or you realize death is an inevitability as it stands now...no matter your religious beliefs.
And I don't think there's anything insane whatsoever about that notion...Your agrument breaks down to something like I've done a lot of bad , might as well grab a shotgun, stick it in my mouth, and do one more.
You don't know that he's schizophrenic...Just based on the way drugs for schizophrenia work, I wonder how much he would be tormented. It seems like the drugs slow everything down in the brain as a way to quiet the 'voices', and put the person into a kind of trance. Not the best way to go through life, but decidedly superior to having your brain misfire and tell you to do all kinds of things that have no basis in reality, and surely better than being 6 feet in the ground.
We don't even know the he's insane. It's a hypothetical.
Let's use your logic.
George Bush
Killed.
Innocent.
Women.
Children.
By.
The.
Thousands.
Based.
On.
A.
ing.
Lie.
Get the gallows and string him up.
Base your stance is inherently contradictory...
I mean for a guy who doesn't understand preferring death you certainly aren't very survival oriented...if you were you'd certainly undestand why plucking his eyes out when he is facing certain execution is far from conclusively the action of a madman...but rather easily also the action of a man who is deperate to survive and get away with murder, as is feigning insanity.
On the one hand you don't seem to understand why plucking his eyes out is better than death and dub that action as clearly insane...and then you turn around and act like anything is better then death if you are sane...
I dub the full of .
Man, you're ing dense. I never argued it was conclusive evidence he was insane. I said it pointed that way. He should be evaluated to see if he really is capable of having a grip on reality.
He was granted that power by the citizens of the United States of America.
And I'd say the fact he is begging for help and vocally pushing for an insanity defense pretty much proves he is sane...an insane person doesn't know they're insane...that's part of what makes them insane. They certainly don't think they need help.
Read the comments of his laywer again and you can see right through his ass...as well as his lawyer.
Then again, if you could see through the bull comments of a lawyer you probably wouldn't have voted Obama in the past election...
I know I know...you did it for the space program.
gotta love the buddah! yep i said it and even though it goes against all this thread entails... you es for stepping on ballijuana's feet just because his nick includes a hint towards bud. bunch of in' pussies in here. marijuana makes you stupid, blah blah blah, we are nothing but pussies, blah blah blah; yeah that's all i'm hearing from all you pussies in this thread.
oh and i could care less what happens to that blind pos.
Not insane, just dumb. All he is doing is working the flawed system.
You really got to quit this . All you did was and whine about how great your dumbass candidate was for blaming all her shortcomings on the gotcha media. Go yourself.
Who the cares if he has a grip on reality..........fry him, what will the world really have lost?
whottts a anyway. hey whottt gay marriage will now be legal in your state too so you should thank mr obama. go suck a !
I'm all for putting his insan y to the detest...I'm just not satisfied with his degree of self mutilation yet...if he cuts out his tongue...maybe cuts off his or nuts...takes off a hand or a couple of feet...I'll give him insanity.
Right now what we know is that he's been ruled sane, is pushing for an insanity plea, and has done nothing so far to prove beyond all doubt he is certifiable.
I want to see how far he's willing to go to prove he's insane...he hasn't gone far enough yet. He's got to at least cut his tongue out.
It makes me laugh when people that support gay marriage call another person a " "
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
