Would you rather have Tony Parker or Deron Williams?

[InRareForm]

hypothetically speaking so it makes the question fair, if deron was accustomed to the spurs system, what player would you rather have on the spurs squad running the show, tony or Deron?

[Destro]

Deron

[superbigtime]

Frenchie.

[DPG21920]

That is tough. Deron I feel is a better all around player, but Tony's skill set is almost custom made for the Spurs system. I would say Tony for the Spurs, but Deron for most all other systems.

[Go For Tree]

theres just something about Tony........ Plus hes still banging Eva. I dont know why that matters but it soooooo does..... sodas?

[Spursfan092120]

Mr. Longoria.
Bottom line, Nets 26-32: Spurs 39-17. It's about leading your team (Tony has shown he's a leader), not about scoring a bunch of points. They have very similar stats this year, but Tony has led a hurting team to a great record, while Harris has led a healthy team to 6 games below .500.

[DPG21920]

Mr. Longoria.
Bottom line, Nets 26-32: Spurs 39-17. It's about leading your team (Tony has shown he's a leader), not about scoring a bunch of points. They have very similar stats this year, but Tony has led a hurting team to a great record, while Harris has led a healthy team to 6 games below .500.

Is this a joke?

[mabrignani]

Mr. Longoria.
Bottom line, Nets 26-32: Spurs 39-17. It's about leading your team (Tony has shown he's a leader), not about scoring a bunch of points. They have very similar stats this year, but Tony has led a hurting team to a great record, while Harris has led a healthy team to 6 games below .500.

derron williams not devin harris my man

[Spursfan092120]

derron williams not devin harris my man

Ooh....lol...guess I read it wrong..my bad..



Still take Tony. For all the same reasons. Better record, better leader. Maybe it's my opinion, but Tony has a Finals MVP, and has led the Spurs in difficult times and good. I wouldn't trade him for any other PG, including Paul.

[InRareForm]

I wouldn't trade him for any other PG, including Paul.

I hate CP3 and his annoying cry baby bag self, but I would take CP3 over TP ABSOULUTELY

[DespЏrado]

I'll keep the proven finals mvp over Deron any day. Deron has yet to prove that he can be a winner at the nba level. He could just be another marbury or Tim hardaway. Always putting up really respectable numbers but never leading a team to the le. Tony has already done that.

[Spursfan092120]

I hate CP3 and his annoying cry baby bag self, but I would take CP3 over TP ABSOULUTELY

I appreciate your opinion. I 100% disagree with it, but I appreciate it.

[tomtom]

Pretty tough, Deron is a damn good player

[Spursfan092120]

I'll keep the proven finals mvp over Deron any day. Deron has yet to prove that he can be a winner at the nba level. He could just be another marbury or Tim hardaway. Always putting up really respectable numbers but never leading a team to the le. Tony has already done that.

Egg Zactly.

[HarlemHeat37]

I would take Deron as well..his size is the key for me..

[Spursfan092120]

That is all...Thank you.

[Typhoon]

I'll keep the proven finals mvp over Deron any day. Deron has yet to prove that he can be a winner at the nba level. He could just be another marbury or Tim hardaway. Always putting up really respectable numbers but never leading a team to the le. Tony has already done that.

[mexicanjunior]

At this stage, I would take Deron. He has such great size and strength at the PG position, makes for alot of great mismatches. Plus, he is able to defend both 2's, 3's and I think is more capable of running this offense more efficiently. Parker is still great though...

[jack sommerset]

This is such a homer question. If you pick Parker you are one

[Banzai]

I'll take both.

[Spurs Brazil]

Tony Parker

CP3 is the only PG playing better than TP this season

[Spursfan092120]

This is such a homer question. If you pick Parker you are one

Stupid comment. Parker is a playoff proven PG with better career stats and has been very clutch. Besides, his style is exactly perfect with the San Antonio Spurs style. What makes us homers for keeping with the PG that has led us to 3 les, while getting a Finals MVP in the process, while Deron has led his team to exactly zero?

[SequSpur]

yall Parker haters.. get the out of this forum... bags.

[Thomas82]

I'll keep the proven finals mvp over Deron any day. Deron has yet to prove that he can be a winner at the nba level. He could just be another marbury or Tim hardaway. Always putting up really respectable numbers but never leading a team to the le. Tony has already done that.

What he said.

[Spursfan092120]

At this stage, I would take Deron. He has such great size and strength at the PG position, makes for alot of great mismatches. Plus, he is able to defend both 2's, 3's and I think is more capable of running this offense more efficiently. Parker is still great though...

While I appreciate your opinion, I'm very confused by the statement. You say Deron is more capable of running this offense more efficiently. The Spurs have one of the hardest offenses in the league, and Deron has never run it. Parker, however, has run it better than any Spurs PG in recent memory, and is definitely in the top 2 PGs this year...either before or right behind CP3. How do you know if Deron would be more capable of running this offense? He's never tried. As a former 1-2 guard in college, different systems change players. Deron may be just average while running SA's offense, you never know.