Sheed or Dice?

[jdev82]

rather have dyce honestly, but you gotta love sheed. if sheed works on his shot and comes to SA in shape, id love him. regardless of techs, hes a smarter player than dyce, and clutcher. dyce is a better rebounder, and wont miss the open ones like sheed. sheed this year reminded me of horry last year. just an awful shooter that you know if he worked at all would still be contributing well.

[Bruno]

If Sheed has still something left in the tank, he would be a tremendous addition.

[jdev82]

The geriatric team, here we go again

yeah cuz young bonner and mason and hill are doing so well in the playoffs

[jdev82]

both are 4000x clutcher than bonner's stupid ass

[lefty]

Sheed is declining and is FAT


No thanks

[Chomag]

Sheed is declining and is FAT


No thanks

From the last 2 years and especially this year I"ll have to agree. He just is adeclining 3 point shooter. However if it's all just lost motivation and not his skills he would be great to have if he could be had at a good price. That being said I would rather have dice because I would think we could get dice at a much cheaper price and more bang fo the buck. Plus it would be nice to have Dice to teach Ian some things.

[peskypesky]

McDyess

[holcs50]

Dude I was excited about possibly getting sheed awhile ago. But damn the guy is pretty bad now. Id probably want mcdyess more because he wont jack up tons of 3s like sheed. Either are better than bonner, but sheed is not what people think, the one thing he'd bring is better d than bonner but other than that not much

[spursbird]

you did realize that Ian and Gist combine for 23 minutes of NBA experience?
no, not minutes per game. that the career total in minutes for both.

we are talking about players, who could become part of the regular rotation and who can contribute immediately. Ian and Gist might both be on the roster. but they will be 9th and 10th in the rotation at best.

Well, compare the minutes Bonner played between this season and last season. Pop's adjustment can never be predicted.

[Spur|n|Austin]

Dice has impressed me this season.

[Morg1411]

No to Wallace. Never been a fan, and he's on the downswing.

McDyess, on the other hand, is some bad , and he's been playing great lately. I'd sign him in a heartbeat. (Yes, I know he's old...that just means he'd fit in...)

[Darrin]

Wondering where the Spurs fans stand on this.....with a major retooling looming in Detroit, there's a strong chance that both Rasheed Wallace and Antonio McDyess will be available (and affordable). Who would you rather see paired with Duncan in SA?

Why not get both? Antonio McDyess is the more skilled of the two players, but Sheed has more size.

[KuntryDude]

Personally, I would love to see the Spurs revert back to what won them the initial Championships.....TWIN TOWERS!!!!! Chris Bosh free agent 2010! WHAT A PAIR!!!!!!!!!!

[Please_dont_ban_me]

Sheed, hands down.


Sheed > McDyess > Gooden

[Please_dont_ban_me]

Personally, I would love to see the Spurs revert back to what won them the initial Championships.....TWIN TOWERS!!!!! Chris Bosh free agent 2010! WHAT A PAIR!!!!!!!!!!

One of the towers might need some structural repair.

[Ed Helicopter Jones]

Finish the Camby trade.

For the right price I'd rather see Camby on the Spurs than Wallace or McDyess.

[Please_dont_ban_me]

For the right price I'd rather see Camby on the Spurs than Wallace or McDyess.

I would have to agree.

I'd probably take Camby over Rasheed. At the right price, of course.

[mingus]

Sheed is old but he still has great defense. The problem is that he is too slow to help cover for other people anymore, but that shouldn't be a concern when he has Tim Duncan with him.

this is exactly why i would rather have Wallace over anyone...

the Spurs will have to ultimately go through the Lakers if they want to win another ring , and each Wallace and Duncan's length and post-defense would give Bynum and Gasol a of a lot of trouble because for the most part , Gasol and Bynum play in the post and aren't going to out-quick you ... Wallace and Duncan still have ability to play great post defense ... Wallace would also be able to help guard Dirk (although Bonner did pretty well on him for the most part) ...

and on offense the Spurs would have the luxary of being able to have Wallace roam behind the 3-point line to keep Bynum or Gasol outside the paint , making it easier for Ginobili and Parker to penetrate ... but he's also crafty enough in the post (when he plays there) to get either one of them in foul trouble ...

... but then there's still the problem of not having a mobile enough 4 or 5 long , or a long or athletic enough 3 , to be able to contain guys like David West and Odom , who are mismatch for the Spurs , right ? ... that's the big question : will Gist be that long/athletic 3 and will Mahinmi be the mobile enough 4 or 5 the Spurs need to guard those guys ... from what i've seen , i think they can both be full those desired roles ...