finally a legit list.
Amare is barely a Top 20 player, let alone the 8th best player in basketball.
It's a good sign only one person has been dumb enough to consider him top 10.
Its just stupid.
durant over CP? Melo over CP? really? Durant and anthony beat paul in one stat, scoring. IGGY OVER CP? Ghazi is a ing idiot
Lebron
CP3
Kobe
Dwade
D12
Dirk
Parker
Deron
Roy
Melo
Lebron
Wade
Kobe
Paul
Howard
Dirk
Mello
Durant
Roy
Parker
Duncan
AMare was top 10 last year!! His efficiency was off the charts after the Shaq trade!
The WEIRD thing about DIRK is he IS a top 5-8 player and was probably (DEFINITELY) a top THREE player from 2005-2007. yet I KID you NOT I have seen some stupid opinions about beloved Dirk at times, such as J-Ho being the best PLAYER on the team (Tim Legler may have said this) or even JASON TERRY (Mashburn?). I've also seen people claim he's not a top fifteen PLAYER and question his hall of fame CREDENTIALS and consider him a STAR, not a superstar. a CROCK all of it I tell you.
Now there are some legitimate criticisms about his marginal DEFENSIVE impact but I think the bottom line is, if you LEAD a team to an NBA CHampionship, like dirk did in 2006, you ARE a world class PLAYER. The CHOKER label holds no merit because 2007 appears to be an ANOMALY rather than the TREND.
1. LeBron
2. Kobe
3. Wade
4. Duncan
5. Howard
6. Dirk
7. CP3
8. Roy
9. Melo
10. Durant
1-lebron/kobe
3-wade
4-howard
5-dirk
6-duncan
7-cp3
8-garnett
9-roy
10-melo
Him and Dirk4mvp...but not necessarily that they're ignorant about basketball, because they're not..it just shows they're Spurs haters...
I'm sorry spurs fans, but I think TP is better than TD now. Both are great, but TP is now the team's MVP
lol they must be one dominant team if they were 7-3 w/o their "MVP" this season.
Saying Roy > Parker doesn't make you a Spurs hater it makes you someone who thinks the best player on a 54 win team is generally better than the 2nd best player on a 54 win team.
It also makes him right.
I'm the one that's saying Roy > Parker.
Agreed except Garnett and Iguodala for Parker, Yao, or Granger
i think Duncan is a top 10 player on offense. trust me as a Mavfan, if i see him take that double pump fake, sweeping hook that bounces off the front of the rim, then the back, then front, backboar and then goes in, one more time i'll puke.
his defense has definitely regresed due to the combination of age and injury
On 2nd thought I overrated Iguodala.
He would be top FIVE if he had a jumper though.
a 7'6 piece of being listed the 9th best player in NBA, though he is perhaps among the top 20 players along his teammate Ron Artest. Melo and Tony Longoria are both controvacial candidates, and it's also ridiculous two top-10 players work on the team which didn't even make the second round this season.
Dirk
Lebron
Dwright
Kobe
Derrick Rose
Duncan
KG
Kevin Durant
Pau Gasol
Jason Kidd
1/2: Lebron/Kobe
3: Dwyane Wade
4: Dirk
5:Tim Duncan
6: Steve Nash
7: Dwight Howard
8: Chris Paul
9: Carmelo
10: Kevin Durant
In no particular order:
Kobe
LeBron
D-Whistle
Howard
Duncan
Dirk
Paul
Roy
Durant
JJ Hickson
Don't believe what those people on the Cavs boards tell you!!!!
1. LeBron James
2a. Dwayne Wade
2b. Kobe Bryant
4a. Dwight Howard
4b. Chris Paul
6a. Tim Duncan
6b. Dirk Nowitzki
8. Brandon Roy
9. Carmelo Anthony
10. Kevin Durant
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)