Pick the best right now: CP3 vs D-Will

[JustBlaze]

Carmelo had four playoff wins over five years before Chauncey Billups showed up, and he also was swept.

What's he done recently? More importantly, what has Paul done recently? Yeah that's right.

[j-money24]

Do you really want me to bring up the stats?

Stats doesn't mean .

I definitely don't need another Hollinger right now.

[redzero]

What's he done recently? More importantly, what has Paul done recently? Yeah that's right.

What has Carmelo done recently? What he couldn't do without Chauncey Billups. Paul carried an injured, depthless Hornets team into the playoffs. What does Carmelo do as the leader and with much better talent around him? Get swept.

[redzero]

Stats doesn't mean .

I definitely don't need another Hollinger right now.

So, you would rather just make claims that aren't backed up by anything? Fine, Brandon Roy and Carmelo Anthony are better than Kobe Bryant. Why? They just are.

[Lars]

Paul is way better. Fourth best player in the league imo.

[JustBlaze]

What has Carmelo done recently? What he couldn't do without Chauncey Billups. Paul carried an injured, depthless Hornets team into the playoffs. What does Carmelo do as the leader and with much better talent around him? Get swept.

Ah, playing the injury card I see. Well, sorry to break it to ya, but your team isn't the only one in the league that plays hurt. As for Paul carrying them into the playoffs, big deal, before Melo got on the team, Nugz only managed to win 17 games their previous year. He's led his team to the playoffs since, what's Pauls excuse in '06 & '07?

[redzero]

Ah, playing the injury card I see. Well, sorry to break it to ya, but your team isn't the only one in the league that plays hurt. As for Paul carrying them into the playoffs, big deal, before Melo got on the team, Nugz only managed to win 17 games their previous year. He's led his team to the playoffs since, what's Pauls excuse in '06 & '07?

lol

Do you know how much talent Carmelo has around him? He is in no way a leader. All he is is a scorer. Paul LED his team, and he made them better.

[kamikazi_player]

i thought we had this debate before, oh well. I give the nod to CP3. He's just simply better than d-will right now. D-will has lots of potential, but CP3 has been more of a threat to most teams than D-will.

[Rogue]

It's one thing to give actual numbers to a player's overall abilities like the video game produces do, but it's quite another thing to calibrate the career of a career. Smokey is definitely a much better player than Breath but Breath's career has much more to brag about in terms of rings, while Smokey doesn't have to boast of.

[JustBlaze]

lol

Do you know how much talent Carmelo has around him? He is in no way a leader. All he is is a scorer. Paul LED his team, and he made them better.

Where EXACTLY did Paul LEAD his team to in '06 & '07? Asides the lottery.

[Clipper Nation]

DWill
Fat
Coach-killer
Overrated
System player
Not elite anymore
Not better than CP3 and never was

[sook]

This isn't even close Paul is the 3rd best player in the league. This was debatable maybe like 4 yrs ago kind of like when Tmac and Kobe were on par, but the comparison is just ridiculous now.

Dwill isn't even in the same league as Paul atm.

[Brunodf]

Overrated Fatass

[Juggity]

Hard to believe there was ever a time when Dwill was considered better than cp3.

[Venti Quattro]

Hard to believe there was ever a time when Dwill was considered better than cp3.

Harder to believe that he actually was before he decided to fall off a cliff.