Should Bogans be waived?

[benefactor]

This is the second ceperez thread about Bogans that has been bumped this week. He needs to come eat some crow.

[MaNu4Tres]

TJastal and ceperez both need to come eat some crow.

[ChumpDumper]

Overall, the Bogans' signing is a stain on what had been a perfect off season of moves.

The Stain had a pretty good game.

[angelbelow]

This is a prime example when fans don't know what the they are talking about.

I agree, fans should never jump to conclusions, especially based off preseason statistics.

However, I can understand cepez's POV too. Bogans was struggling and he did bring up a few good points. And he didn't suggest that Bogans absolutely be waived. Overall he was looking out for the team, which is a positive thing imo.

The audience that I simply cannot tolerate are those that flat out say "we went over the luxury tax for this??" or "trade RJ!"

[TJastal]

I ate some crow already in the church of Bogans thread.

I've been really harsh on Bogans, partly because I thought Hairston was deserving of the opportunity that Keith is getting. Sucks for Hairston, but Bogans is proving he was a very shrewd pickup for pennies on the dollar.

I should have listened to you guys about Bogans.

[raspsa]

The Stain had a pretty good game.

Hey "Stain" is a good nickname for Bogan and his defense if he can keep it up.. as in "can't get the stain out of my######...

[PM5K]

However, I can understand cepez's POV too.

I'm going to have to disagree with you there. After reading this thread one would easily be able to decipher between those that had actually seen Bogans play and those that looked at a box score to decide how good of a player they think he is.

You can't judge a player based on just his box score.

[TJastal]

I'm going to have to disagree with you there. After reading this thread one would easily be able to decipher between those that had actually seen Bogans play and those that looked at a box score to decide how good of a player they think he is.

You can't judge a player based on just his box score.

I don't care how good a guy's defense is, if you go 1-19 in the pre-season your not going to be judged well.