Reply With Quote
VY and Tebow are definitely in it. And after becoming the winningest QB in NCAA history, McCoy probably would be in it with a NT win, too.
say the longhorns win the NC this year...
are these the three greatest college QBs of all time?
VY and Tebow are definitely in it. And after becoming the winningest QB in NCAA history, McCoy probably would be in it with a NT win, too.
not colt or tebow, ive seen too much colt, even im tired of his act
mookie2001 must be tired of winning
Doug Flutie?????
no
No.
They're the 3 greatest QBs on the century.
mook..dude..you gotta be kidding, bro. Most wins in NCAA history, best accuracy in NCAA history, nice guy, role model, winner. You're tired of that?
yeah
hes reached his limitations as a qb, i can tell a split second after the snap where hes going with the ball
i root like for the guy but his fumbling, his awww shucks my bible act, its tired
i know gilbert is going to have growing pains but im ready for the next chapter
how bout harrell?
shut the up please
Dude..McCoy is a beast. I'll always have a soft spot for Vince and he'll probably always be my favorite for bringing Texas back to the top, but McCoy is better, IMO. Gilbert will be good, but he's no McCoy, man...
Four years ago you were probably saying the same thing about VY/Colt.
lol...you're exactly right..I was. And I may turn out to be wrong...I hope so.
I don't know about that.
Do you think Colt could have done what VY did against USC? No way. Colt's a better passer, but VY was the best college QB ever. No QB ever could singlehandedly take-over and dominate games the way VY was able to. Thats why I still would take him over Tebow as well. Tebow is great, but he doesnt just dominate games the way VY would, and has a much more gimmicky system to benefit from. Basically, it's easier to find a gameplan to stop McCoy or Tebow than it is for Vince.
That's a great argument, stretch. It actually kinda made me think about it a bit. You might be right.
I just think there are too many variables in the college game to form a consensus at the QB position. There are probably 10-15 QBs who you could legitimately argue that deserve to be included in the top 5.
Plus, what do you do with small school, lower division guys like Neil Lomax and Steve McNair who absolutely obliterated everyone they played?
Tommie Frazier
Tommie Frazier >> Colt or Tebow
He was even the MVP in the NC game in the loss against Charlie Ward and Fla St.
Hard to compare a lot of college players because the ones that have pro potential usually leave early.
Even though Vince had maybe the best season ever as a QB, Frazier had the better overall college career.
or guys like Detmer who get dinged because of the system they played in.
Tebow. Colt. VY.
Two worship Jesus, one is black Jesus.
IMO Tebow gets overrated as because of the NC that Chris Leak won for Florida.
How can you say Tommie Frazier had a better college career than Colt McCoy has? In what insane way can you back that up?
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
