Who is the best quarterback?

[Rapper]

Peyton Manning or Tom Brady?

I start to love watching American football games although i am one of the few chinese who knows the rule

Just want to ask you guys who is the best

[Drachen]

Peyton Manning or Tom Brady?

I start to love watching American football games although i am one of the few chinese who knows the rule

Just want to ask you guys who is the best

Manning, plus he is freakin funny!

[peewee's lovechild]

Tony Romo.

[I. Hustle]

Quincy Carter. Hands down. The. Best. Ever.

[Thunder Dan]

Brady Quinn

[peewee's lovechild]

Brady Quinn

FOR THE WIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!






End thread now please.

[pawe]

Brady Quinn

Better than Jamarcus Russel? I dont think so.

[DAF86]

Martin Gramatica.

[dirk4mvp]

steamin willie beamen

[J.T.]

Peyton Manning

Super Bowl Champion
Super Bowl MVP
3-time NFL MVP (might soon be 4)
Top 5 in most if not all QB stat categories (and well ahead of pace to be #1 in all of them before his career is over)
22 straight wins and counting
114 wins in a decade and counting

Tom Brady

3x Super Bowl Champion
2x Super Bowl MVP
NFL MVP
Got caught cheating
The goat for the two biggest choke jobs in NFL history

It's Manning by 100 miles

[lefty]

Jean-Franceois De Percival

[Blake]

Graham Harrell

[Cry Havoc]

@ Colts fan who answers the question seriously.

[Frenzy]

Peyton Manning

Super Bowl Champion
Super Bowl MVP
3-time NFL MVP (might soon be 4)
not caught cheating yet
Top 5 in most if not all QB stat categories (and well ahead of pace to be #1 in all of them before his career is over)

Tom Brady

3x Super Bowl Champion
2x Super Bowl MVP
NFL MVP
Got caught cheating
argumentatively the goat for the two biggest choke jobs in NFL history

Fixed and removed the jargon that had nothing to to with comparing. By going with the provided stats it's pretty much tied if you going by hash marks.


Plus I care for neither teams.

[BlackSwordsMan]

troll - 1

[stretch]

manning definitely

[Thunder Dan]

[TheGodfather]

3 Super Bowl wins to one. I'm sorry- what were the other stats?

Brady- big tme.

[slayermin]

Philip Rivers

[CubanSucks]

All joking aside I'd take Brady over Manning in any big game. 1 superbowl isn't gonna cut it for who apparently is gonna end up being "the greatest ever"

[Cry Havoc]

All joking aside I'd take Brady over Manning in any big game. 1 superbowl isn't gonna cut it for who apparently is gonna end up being "the greatest ever"

Wow, that's a ridiculous take. So you'd take Brady over Manning because he's had teams that have an all-star lineup around him, while Manning is currently unbeaten with a team that doesn't even have a running game?

[CubanSucks]

Wow, that's a ridiculous take. So you'd take Brady over Manning because he's had teams that have an all-star lineup around him, while Manning is currently unbeaten with a team that doesn't even have a running game?

yeah

[peewee's lovechild]

DAF86,

Your sig.

It's giving me a chub.

[Greg Oden]

All joking aside I'd take Brady over Manning in any big game. 1 superbowl isn't gonna cut it for who apparently is gonna end up being "the greatest ever"

The AFC Championship and Superbowl from a couple years ago want a word with you.

[760Spursfan]

better than jamarcus russel? I dont think so.

+1


Who would you take Jamarcus Russell or Ryan Leaf???