Reply With Quote
How do you explain turning it over twice as much as Romo?
Anybody can just go out there and sling it all over the place because they have no run game, but it doesn't do any good if you keep turning it over
Romo also has an incredible run game on his side while Schaub doesn't. The Texans are probably at the bottom 5 in rushing as a team. That doesn't help the play action, which is a big part of the pass offense. If you swap Schaub and Romo I think Schaub would be putting up even better numbers. Romo would be playing like the above average QB that he really is.
How do you explain turning it over twice as much as Romo?
Anybody can just go out there and sling it all over the place because they have no run game, but it doesn't do any good if you keep turning it over
Stupid thread. Once Tony Romo gets a receiver like Andre Johnson, we can talk again.
Miles Austin > Andre Johnson
It can't be explained. He makes poor decisions from time to time. That doesn't change the fact that he is still significantly better than Romo in almost every statistical category with a lot less. Sure he has a great WR, Romo doesn't have anyone even remotely close to AJ, but Romo does have 3 good RBs and a great TE. Owen Daniels has been out for most of the season and aside from AJ, no other WR has stepped up for Houston, yet Schaub is still statistically better.
If it was the other way around, and Romo had better stats but turned the ball over twice as much as Schaub, you'd point to that as the reason why Schaub was better.
Peyton Manning has 15 INTS this season. Does this make Romo a better QB than Manning?
Manning is the best QB in the league...you're saying Schaub having better stats makes him better than Romo, when he's got a much better receiver. When Romo had T.O., he was much better than Schaub stat-wise. Having a great receiver is a of a lot better than having a great TE, because Johnson can outrun 75% of the DBs in the league...Witten can't outrun any of them. And to top it off, some of those passes DID go to Owen Daniels this year. But thanks for throwing this point out, because all it does is show your point is moot. Stats aren't everything.
QBs get all the acclaim when a team wins and all the blame when a team loses.
Who's team has a better record?
I guess Joe Montana wasn't a great QB since he had Jerry Rice. I see what you are saying.
So according to your criteria what makes Romo better than Schaub? The star on his helmet?
The fact that year in and year out, Tony is right there at the top, and Schaub isn't always there...the fact that they Cowboys win more games than the Texans...if December Romo showed up this year, I might actually agree that Schaub might be better, but Romo is showing this year that he's a better player. He's also performing well under a MUCH larger spotlight than Schaub, with no clear cut top WR.
Just because that is the going assumption doesn't make it true. Just look at the loss to the Tacks in week 10. Schaub threw for over 300 yards, 2 TD's, no picks and had a passer rating of 105.2. The loss clearly was not his fault.
This is Schaub's 3rd year as a starter and last season and this season he was near the top statistically, even with his shortened season last year due to injuries. The rest of your argument is just opinion. The facts are in numbers.
The spotlight argument is bull . Also, I thought you had a huge boner for Miles Austin and already proclaimed him a top WR. Now you backtrack?
But yet when Romo throws for 300 yards, gets a couple of TDs, and the Cowboys lose, you bash Romo. What a hypocrite.
Yet when Schaub has better season stats with less offensive weapons aside from an all-world WR you bash him and say Romo is better. ing hypocrite.
I think you're mistaken about Miles...yes, I think he's the best receiver we have, but he's not near Andre Johnson's level. I've said all year that Andre is the best WR in the league. If the facts are in numbers, why did you throw out that Peyton has more INTs than Romo? You're not helping your argument. Stats are obviously not everything. And if you think the spotlight argument is bull , you're ignorant. NY and Dallas are the two hardest places to play as a NFL QB in the league.
Do I? Evidence please.
Now I do laugh at the Cowboys as a whole when they lose. But hey, who doesn't?
That all world WR is enough..and he had Daniels for some of this season. Like I said before, Andre Johnson can outrun 75% of the DBs in this league..Witten can't outrun any of them. Johnson can do a double move and take off on a fly pattern and Schaub can just throw the ball up and he'll get to it. Witten can't do that. When Romo had TO, he was a lot better..that "All World WR" thing matters..a LOT.
lol Romo is your response to Cowboy losses...so yeah, you do.
This is just a butthurt Texans fans thread, pissed off that the Cowboys remain better than Houston, despite their pleas, and the fact that Dallas could beat an undefeated team hurts them even more. Get over yourselves...you're not on Dallas' level yet..
lmao insecure Cowboys fan playing the "Shudddup! We're better than you!" card in a thread about two individual players.
Look, they are both very close. I have watched Schaub play all season, and he is very good.
Looking at the stats, he is better in every stat but not by a whole lot. One thing that does stand out, like a tiebreaker, is the INT and Schaub has TWICE as many. I have not followed the Texans closely but it seems like he makes crucial mistakes at the wrong time a lot.
And there is no debate about the fact that the Cowboys are 100 times more scrutinized than the freakin Texans.Off the top of my head (there may have been more) i remember watching Schaub screw up and throw an INT with the game tied against AZ that Cromartie took to the house for the win. They may have spent about 2 minutes about that on ESPN, if that was Romo, half the show would have aired coverage on it and speculation about him being cut would run through the papers all week.
LMAO..insecure? We're 9-5 and in charge of our own destiny...the Texans need a damn miracle to make the playoffs. Texans fans bash on Cowboys and their fans all the time in here..who's insecure??
This thread is just for discussion on whether or not Schaub is better than Romo. Nothing more. The Cowboys are the better team and the record shows it. I have no problem stating that.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions