Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 25 of 40
  1. 02-07-2010 #1
    PGDynasty24
    Believe. PGDynasty24's Avatar
    Post Count
    2,041
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote PGDynasty24 is offline
  2. 02-07-2010 #2
    dbreiden83080
    Veteran dbreiden83080's Avatar
    Post Count
    20,159
    Elway and Manning are both better than Montana... He played on all time great teams..
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote dbreiden83080 is offline
  3. 02-07-2010 #3
    Dr. Gonzo
    Master of Information Dr. Gonzo's Avatar
    My Team
    Houston Texans
    Post Count
    8,678
    Yes he does. How many did Elway lose before he won one?
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Dr. Gonzo is offline
  4. 02-07-2010 #4
    dbreiden83080
    Veteran dbreiden83080's Avatar
    Post Count
    20,159
    Quote Originally Posted by Dr. Gonzo
    Yes he does. How many did Elway lose before he won one?
    3 and he sucked in them..
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote dbreiden83080 is offline
  5. 02-07-2010 #5
    mytespurs
    Veteran
    Post Count
    1,507
    The one thing I will say about the Colts is that as long as Peyton is QB and stays healthy, they will be back in the big game.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote mytespurs is offline
  6. 02-07-2010 #6
    dbreiden83080
    Veteran dbreiden83080's Avatar
    Post Count
    20,159
    Quote Originally Posted by mytespurs
    The one thing I will say about the Colts is that as long as Peyton is QB and stays healthy, they will be back in the big game.
    Probably..
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote dbreiden83080 is offline
  7. 02-07-2010 #7
    dbreiden83080
    Veteran dbreiden83080's Avatar
    Post Count
    20,159
    Manning's stats

    31/45 333 1/1

    He played well the D as usual not so good..
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote dbreiden83080 is offline
  8. 02-07-2010 #8
    ducks
    bandwagoner fans suck ducks's Avatar
    Post Count
    74,377
    Quote Originally Posted by mytespurs
    The one thing I will say about the Colts is that as long as Peyton is QB and stays healthy, they will be back in the big game.


    they better not play the chargers
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote ducks is offline
  9. 02-07-2010 #9
    Fabbs
    Believe. Fabbs's Avatar
    Post Count
    15,577
    The interception looked like a total puss out by Reggie Wayne.

    The final goaline drop by Wayne without question a puss out. Perfect pass.

    Montana did not have to deal with idiotic drops. Except the one by the Cincinatti db who had it right in his hands.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Fabbs is offline
  10. 02-07-2010 #10
    Kermit
    go balls deep for jesus Kermit's Avatar
    My Team
    Dallas Cowboys
    Post Count
    4,720
    Quote Originally Posted by ducks


    they better not play the chargers
    The Chargers suck.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Kermit is offline
  11. 02-07-2010 #11
    Pistons < Spurs
    My Playlist > Yours Pistons < Spurs's Avatar
    Post Count
    27,176
    He's definitely in the conversation right now, and once his career has ended, he will be the undisputed G.O.A.T. in my opinion.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Pistons < Spurs is offline
  12. 02-07-2010 #12
    DisgruntledLionFan#54,927
    Che cazzo stai dicendo? DisgruntledLionFan#54,927's Avatar
    Post Count
    7,801
    Quote Originally Posted by Pistons < Spurs
    He's definitely in the conversation right now, and once his career has ended, he will be the undisputed G.O.A.T. in my opinion.
    People used to say that about Favre.

    Not so much anymore.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote DisgruntledLionFan#54,927 is offline
  13. 02-07-2010 #13
    ShoogarBear
    Hedo Layup Drill ShoogarBear's Avatar
    Post Count
    39,519
    Quote Originally Posted by Pistons < Spurs
    He's definitely in the conversation right now, and once his career has ended, he will be the undisputed G.O.A.T. in my opinion.
    Until Brady Quinn gets his roll on.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote ShoogarBear is offline
  14. 02-07-2010 #14
    SpuronyourFace
    Im on a boat SpuronyourFace's Avatar
    Post Count
    602
    A win tonight would of really propelled him.

    He's still great however.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote SpuronyourFace is offline
  15. 02-07-2010 #15
    DisgruntledLionFan#54,927
    Che cazzo stai dicendo? DisgruntledLionFan#54,927's Avatar
    Post Count
    7,801
    Quote Originally Posted by ShoogarBear
    Until Brady Quinn gets his roll on.
    And Colt Brennan.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote DisgruntledLionFan#54,927 is offline
  16. 02-07-2010 #16
    bostonguy
    What? bostonguy's Avatar
    Post Count
    4,011
    He has to win a few more superbowls. He threw a pick at the worst time today. While Manning was better than Brady this season, Brady>>>>>>Manning in terms of overall career. Today especially late in that 4th keeps Brady ahead.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote bostonguy is offline
  17. 02-07-2010 #17
    dbreiden83080
    Veteran dbreiden83080's Avatar
    Post Count
    20,159
    Quote Originally Posted by DisgruntledLionFan#54,927
    People used to say that about Favre.

    Not so much anymore.
    Favre is not in Mannings league..
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote dbreiden83080 is offline
  18. 02-07-2010 #18
    IronMexican
    Ina world of hype, we win IronMexican's Avatar
    My Team
    Oakland Raiders
    Post Count
    24,616
    I can't put Peyton in that discussion after today.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote IronMexican is offline
  19. 02-07-2010 #19
    Agloco
    selbstverständlich Agloco's Avatar
    My Team
    Indianapolis Colts
    Post Count
    9,019
    Quote Originally Posted by dbreiden83080
    Elway and Manning are both better than Montana... He played on all time great teams..
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Agloco is offline
  20. 02-07-2010 #20
    scanry
    ... scanry's Avatar
    My Team
    New England Patriots
    Post Count
    4,962
    If a game is on the line, i'm picking Brady 10 times out of 10 over Manning....

    Manning was lucky Rex was QB'ing the Bears.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote scanry is offline
  21. 02-07-2010 #21
    dbreiden83080
    Veteran dbreiden83080's Avatar
    Post Count
    20,159
    Quote Originally Posted by Agloco
    Heck of a debate..

    Lets just count rings up

    Steve Kerr GOAT
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote dbreiden83080 is offline
  22. 02-07-2010 #22
    Agloco
    selbstverständlich Agloco's Avatar
    My Team
    Indianapolis Colts
    Post Count
    9,019
    Quote Originally Posted by bostonguy
    He has to win a few more superbowls. He threw a pick at the worst time today. While Manning was better than Brady this season, Brady>>>>>>Manning in terms of overall career. Today especially late in that 4th keeps Brady ahead.
    This.

    I'm a big Manning fan, but outside of their SB run in 2007 Peyton hasn't done anything spectacular in the postseason.....especially in the 4th quarter.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Agloco is offline
  23. 02-07-2010 #23
    dbreiden83080
    Veteran dbreiden83080's Avatar
    Post Count
    20,159
    Quote Originally Posted by Agloco
    This.

    I'm a big Manning fan, but outside of their SB run in 2007 Peyton hasn't done anything spectacular in the postseason.....especially in the 4th quarter.
    He's probably the best reg season QB ever with 1 ring a Superbowl MVP and he got them to another one. He's got 3 or 4 big years left in him still and he's top 5 right now..
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote dbreiden83080 is offline
  24. 02-07-2010 #24
    Agloco
    selbstverständlich Agloco's Avatar
    My Team
    Indianapolis Colts
    Post Count
    9,019
    Quote Originally Posted by dbreiden83080
    Heck of a debate..

    Lets just count rings up

    Steve Kerr GOAT
    reductio ad absurdum.

    Manning doesn't belong in any GOAT conversation, even if he had won tonight.

    One could make a case for Elway, just not over Joe Cool IMO.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Agloco is offline
  25. 02-07-2010 #25
    bostonguy
    What? bostonguy's Avatar
    Post Count
    4,011
    Quote Originally Posted by dbreiden83080
    He's probably the best reg season QB ever with 1 ring a Superbowl MVP and he got them to another one. He's got 3 or 4 big years left in him still and he's top 5 right now..
    Next year the Colts are ed. The team who looses the superbowl has a down year the next. That has been consistent.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote bostonguy is offline
« Previous Thread | Next Thread »

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

Forum Rules