The judging of the lightweight le bout between former in bent B.J. Penn and Frankie Edgar confirmed the worst fears of every fan paying close attention to the judging trends in MMA -- that it was a matter of time before substandard judging ruined a le bout. Bad judging decisions have become a fact of life in MMA, and nearly every UFC card has at least one judge striving to put together the most nonsensical approach to scoring possible.
The fact that all three judges scored the bout for Edgar was bad enough, but two of them saw it as a lopsided bout. A supposedly lopsided bout that Penn clearly won, at absolute worst, three rounds of by any objective measure. Full credit is due to Edgar for surviving a difficult first two rounds and occasionally landing some clean punches on Penn as the bout dragged on, but he simply did not deserve to win a judges’ decision.