Is Rondo a Top 5 PG?

[thedong]

sons just off the top of my head here is a list of power forwards better than Dirk ...

Tim Duncan (obviously)
Chris Bosh
Amare Stoudemire
David Lee
Kevin Garnett
Pau Gasol
David West
Zach Randolph
Al Jerfferson
Carlos Boozer

and sons that's just a list of current active players.

This confirms it.

Dirk tapped that asssssssss!!!

I heard that BRHornets tried to report this interracial ing incident with the NAACP, but even Al Sharpton laughed when BR told him that Zach Randolph is better than Dirk.

''I can't run with that son''

[Smooth Criminal]

Rondo is w/o a doubt

[redzero]

I always liked Williams better than Paul, regardless of injuries. Deron is just a guy who's incredibly good at everything.

And Paul is better at everything.


And at a Mavs fan calling somebody a loser.

[DesignatedT]

1. Steve Nash
2. Deron Williams
3. Chris Paul
4. Tony Parker
5. Rondo
6. Billups
7. Rose

Kidd,Brooks,Arenas,Evans,Harris,Nelson,Bdiddy- 2nd tier

[dirk4mvp]

Derrick Rose and Nash over TP? Interesting. Rondo is #5 on my list, provided you included TP and took out Rose/Nash.

Tony Parker

Not even the most extreme spur homers can make a case for him being in the top 5, but somehow they do.

[MmP]

It's amazing that Nash is still up there with what? 36? He's amazing

[dirk4mvp]

And Paul is better at everything.


And at a Mavs fan calling somebody a loser.

at hornetfan 'ing at someone calling their franchise a loser.

[BRHornet45]

1. Steve Nash
2. Deron Williams
3. Chris Paul
4. Tony Parker
5. Rondo
6. Billups
7. Rose

Kidd,Brooks,Arenas,Evans,Harris,Nelson,Bdiddy- 2nd tier

ROTFLMAO! now sons lets not show our blatant racism or anything! LOL Nash #1

[redzero]

at hornetfan 'ing at someone calling their franchise a loser.

at dirk4mvp at me for at a Mavs fan for at Chris Paul not the Hornets franchise.

[DPG21920]

Tony Parker

Not even the most extreme spur homers can make a case for him being in the top 5, but somehow they do.

Guy, I made my case for TP over Rose and no one brought anything to the table.

Not for this year's play, but if you are using logic and projecting, TP is top 5.

[DesignatedT]

ROTFLMAO! now sons lets not show our blatant racism or anything! LOL Nash #1

If i had to pick a PG for 1 game it would be Nash. therefore i feel hes the best.

[LakerHater]

I dunno... I'd take Westbrook, Kidd, Conley, Bibby, Billups, Jennings or Brooks over Rondo!!


Even Baron Davis, Andre Miller... even Stephen Curry, but Rondo... NAH!

[Roddy Beaubois]

Not for this year's play, but if you are using logic and projecting, TP is top 5.

So Rose was better this year. Rose is younger and is still getting better. Yet logic says TP will be better next year?

ok.

[DPG21920]

So Rose was better this year. Rose is younger and is still getting better. Yet logic says TP will be better next year?

ok.

Rose was only better because TP was hurt. Even in Rose's best year (this one), he never really approached TP's best year (which was just one year ago). It is not like it is logical to expect TP to fall off a cliff.

[Ice009]

Tp is definitely not top 5 this year. He was very, very average compared to his standards. Injury and fatigue played a big factor in that though. Let's see how he goes next season because last season he was clearly top 3 and approaching Superstar level play for a good 3-4 months.

I wonder if Rondo is being slightly overrated though. He is great and I love the way he is playing, but I'd like to see Rondo on an average team that isn't loaded like the Celtics are.

Russell Westbrook is someone I was impressed with this season. He just needs to clean up his game a little bit though as he makes dumb mistakes sometimes with turnovers and throws up bad shots, but otherwise he is a beast and he really started to put it together just before the playoffs and into the playoffs.

[LakerHater]

I wonder if Rondo is being slightly overrated though. He is great and I love the way he is playing, but I'd like to see Rondo on an average team that isn't loaded like the Celtics are.

Thats what I was thinking, hes got a good player for each position & still leads the team in TOs!

[redzero]

I can understand putting Nash ahead of Paul because of the injuries, but there is no reason to put Nash ahead of Deron Williams.

[DPG21920]

It is because of Nash's playoff run.

[LakerHater]

It is because of Nash's playoff run.

i think thats why everyone is high on Rondo! In Nash's defense, he was consistant through out the regular & playoff season!

Rondo was quite untill playoffs!

[8FOR!3]

1. CP3
2. Deron
3. Parker
4. Rondo
5. Nash
6. Rose

So the answer is yes. Keep in mind that Deron Williams and Chris Paul are virtually interchangeable 1st and 2nd best PGs this year.

[dirk4mvp]

1. CP3
2. Deron
3. Parker
4. Rondo
5. Nash
6. Rose

So the answer is yes. Keep in mind that Deron Williams and Chris Paul are virtually interchangeable 1st and 2nd best PGs this year.

[dirk4mvp]

I dunno... I'd take Westbrook, Kidd, Conley, Bibby, Billups, Jennings or Brooks over Rondo!!


Even Baron Davis, Andre Miller... even Stephen Curry, but Rondo... NAH!

No you wouldn't. Unless you're slow in the brain. I didn't bold Westbrook cause that might be somewhat debatable (with Rondo still winning), but any of the others aren't really close bro.

[DPG21920]

Yeah, at this point, even if you hate Rondo, listing those dudes you did over him is just not really arguable.

[LakerHater]

No you wouldn't. Unless you're slow in the brain. I didn't bold Westbrook cause that might be somewhat debatable (with Rondo still winning), but any of the others aren't really close bro.

You can really place anyone of them in Rondo's position & they'd have a wayyy better season but, you can't place Rondo on any of their teams cuz hed struggle very badly!!!

[dirk4mvp]

You can really place anyone of them in Rondo's position & they'd have a wayyy better season but, you can't place Rondo on any of their teams cuz hed struggle very badly!!!

Based on what? Rondo being the Celtic's best player?