...using the console games' rating system. I picked this topic up from *drumroll* Club Lakers.
Here's my rating for the 2010-2011 LA Lakers...
Kobe - 95
Pau - 91
Bynum (healthy) - 81
Odom - 78
Artest - 75
Barnes - 75
Blake - 74
Shannon - 72
Fisher - 71
Sasha - 68
Luke - 63
Ratliff - 63
Caracter - 59
Ebanks - 57
How does it make any sense to give Barnes the same rating as Artest?..
He's a significantly worse defender, he's just as bad of a shooter, he has less ability to create offense..he doesn't do many things better than Artest, at least not enough to make up for Artest's massive defensive advantage..
I agree with Harlem,Barnes should be like a 69
Bonner regular season - 78
Playoffs - 47
Ginobili 100
Duncan 99
Parker 95
Hill 92
Splitter 89
Bonner 86
86
Dice/Dirk-stopper 85 (only cus hes getting older)
Anderson 84
Hairston 82
Neal 81
Mahinmi 42
why are u rating a dude on the mavs
Fkla
Rodney Stuckey - 77
Rip Hamilton - 79
Tayshaun Prince - 79
Charlie Villanueva - 71
Ben Wallace - 74
Greg Monroe - 75
Jonas Jerebko - 80
Ben Gordon - 81
Will Bynum - 75
Tracy McGrady - 71
Austin Daye - 70
Jason Maxiell - 69
Dajuan Summers - 65
Chris Wilcox - 61
Terrico White - 55
Overall: 72.1
All in all, the Pistons are two superstars and a couple of interior defenders away from having a playoff contender. Unfortunately, with no cap space, the Pistons are not going to be able to maintain the talent they have and add those great players through trades. They could through the draft, but it's unlikely they lose for the next two years and keep a winning culture. They would have to draft exceptionally well.
Hamilton and Prince will be out of their prime, Ben Wallace is likely to retire, and diminish before then, and make the situation worse with regards to rebounding and defense . Without a traditional point guard, the Pistons are going to run the offense through those two great players they are supposed to draft. Greg Monroe, if he becomes one of those great players, would help the Pistons intiate the offense, crash the boards, and defend the interior. Austin Daye could become another average talent but it is unlikely that he becomes a superstar or a leading offensive weapon.
In short, this team sucks and will until they break up the team and start over (trading Villanueva and Gordon for cap space, letting Hamilton and Prince walk, not overpay for anyone else).
Last edited by Darrin; 08-14-2010 at 06:32 PM.
walton - 0
Based on last season:
Duncan - 90
Ginobili - 90
Parker - 89
Splitter - 87
Hill - 85
Jefferson - 80
McDyess - 79
Blair - 75
Bonner - 68
Temple - 60
Gee - 55
Jerrells - 44
Anderson - ?
Neal - ?
Current signed players for 10-11 ...
Paul - 96
West - 86
Thornton - 82
Okafor - 75
Ariza - 75 (?)
Peja - 58
Darius Songaila - 52
Aaron Gray - 04
I'd give Ariza a high 70 to a low 80. On my custom roster on 2K9, I have him at 79, and I'd say that's good. I really think he's gonna be a lot better with the Hornets than he woulda been at the Rockets.
I forgot my roster... jeez.
Yao (Healthy) - 88
Martin - 87
Brooks - 86
Scola - 85
Battier - 80
Lowry - 79
Lee- 78 (Not too sure, but if he was a starter on a Finals team, then he can't be that bad.)
Budinger- 77
Miller - 77
Hill - 77
Patterson - 76
Jeffries - 72
Hayes-74
Taylor - 72
Still a lot of work to do if we want to truly contend.
Duncan - 87
Parker- 81
Ginobili -83
Hill - 70
Blair - 65
Splitter - 68
McDyess- 64
Bonner - 57
Anderson - 61
Neal - 53
Temple - 58
Gee- 56
Jefferson - 70
Based on the calculations of 2k10, this should be close to the ratings next season. They value all-around game more than dominance in one area so guys like Rajon Rondo will have a significantly higher rating than real life efficiency as opposed to a shooter like Matt Bonner who isn't good in any other areas who will suffer from the overall ratings.
Duncan-89
Parker-84
Ginobili-86
Jefferson-74
Hill-79
Blair-74
Splitter-72
McDyess-70
Bonner-69
Anderson-72
Neal-64
Temple-65
Gee-67
Splitter has not played one NBA game and is already better than Dice?
Utah Jazz
Deron Williams-93
Al Jefferson -86 ( He was 84 when he was healthy)
Paul Millsap-78
Kirelinko - 76
Gorden Hayward- 68
Raja Bell-73
Cj Miles- 70
Ronnie Price -64
Gaines - 58
Okur-70
Fesenko- 54
David Andersen - 67
Marcus Banks - 64
Leandro Barbosa - 72
Andrea Bargnani - 78
Jose Calderon - 73
Ed Davis - 65
DeMar DeRozan - 70
Joey Dorsey - 63
Reggie Evans - 65
Jarrett Jack - 74
Linas Kleiza - 67
Sonny Weems - 70
Amir Johnson - 66
Last edited by resistanze; 08-15-2010 at 11:50 PM.
A bit off topic but do you expect Bargnani to have a break out season next year? And do you expect Jose Calderon to be traded?
you forgot Amir
I expect them to lean heavily on Bargnani for offensive output, but I'm not sure how well he'll respond. I predict something like a 19/8 season, on 45% shooting.
I was heartbroken when Jordan pull the Calderon/Evens for Diaw/Chandler trade off the table. The er decided to become a good GM when it was my team. Calderon should be traded, he'd make a serviceable backup on many contenders. At one point I thought he was the best backup in the NBA - the mistake was making him into a starter. Now hes making too much money and in a role he's not supposed to be in.
Oh yeah. LOL $35 million.
Kobe-97
Pau-92
Bynum-83
LO-79
Artest-84
Fisher-74
Blake-77
Brown-72
Barnes-69
Ratliff-65
I forgot my roster... jeez.
Yao (Healthy)- 88
Martin - 87
Brooks - 86
Scola - 85
Battier - 80
Lowry - 79
Lee- 78 (Not too sure, but if he was a starter on a Finals team, then he can't be that bad.)
Budinger- 77
Miller - 77
Hill - 77
Patterson - 76
Jeffries - 72
Hayes-74
Taylor - 72
Still a lot of work to do if we want to truly contend.
Kobe - 97
Pau - 92
Bynum - 80
Odom - 79
Artest - 81
Barnes - 72
Blake - 74
Shannon - 70
Fisher - 71
Sasha - 69
Luke - 62
Ratliff - 63
Caracter - 60
Ebanks - 60
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
