sure he's a young trade asset, but thats not all youve been saying...youre making homerish claims about him having wayyyy more trade value than george hill. you do know that george hill, even before last season's strong 2nd half and playoffs, was a key piece in a package to get VC from the Nets? that when the spurs ask about any established player hill is always the young key player teams want in return?
hill > roddy right now...both as a player and as a trade asset.
i wont dispute that, im simply saying roddy's potential alone couldnt grab sjax or gwall...wallace isnt even that old btw. pretty sure he's still in his late 20s, he came into the league from hs if im not mistaken. and tbh dallas' window is closing just as fast as the spurs' window is, not sure they can afford to wait for roddy develope (if he even developes) since dirk isnt getting any younger.
Last edited by FkLA; 01-25-2011 at 02:47 PM.
If mavs rent a melo, and the knicks give up a few pieces to make the deal work, I could see roddy landing in NY, not too far fetched. Denver doesnt have a need for roddy with Ty Lawson and afflalo, smith, etc... NY may be able use him tho, and you guys can't keep Chandler if you want melo this summer can you? Maybe denver is interested in Chandler?
So Ty Lawson and Afflalo > Steve Nash + Tony Parker + Derrick Rose?
Interesting.
Nuggz have no need for the next coming of French Alah????
If i'm Melo I just play out the season at this point.
Go to NYC this summer, it's clear teams might be getting fed up with the Denver front office and their asking price.
Well how about this. In a survey this summer when the GMs were asked which international player they most expect to have a break out season, roddy garnered at least twice the amount of votes than anyone else...... And the mavs were also offered multiple top ten lotto picks for him. Good enough for you? Does it kill you to know the mavs might have a special talent on their hands? Obviously
sup, are u a general manager???
in what tier of players is roddy b in...give some examples of the type of players that would warrant trading him? a straight up swap too, not packaged witt butler. im trying to get a feel of just how much general managers value roddy b's potential tbh
EXACTLY. It's a small sample size. Which is why the wise thing to do here is to err on the side of caution. You don't watch someone play for 15 games and then proclaim them to be the next superstar with a skillset combining the best traits of 3 top point guards in the league.
Watching JJ Barea play against us the past two years I would have guaranteed you that he was the next Steve Nash. One game or series doesn't mean much.If you've seen the guy play (and there's no way you could have missed him if you watched game 6 last season), then you'd understand the hype surrounding him. He's our best young asset, of course he's not worth a melo for a half season.
LOL mavfan resorting to GM polls
Yeah Roddy and JJB have the same games. It's clear one won't be better than the other.
it's clear to everyone except mavfans
It may have increased his price, it's done nothing to increase his value.
Back to 6/28 is overwhelming, are we?
Would you like to start a poll for other teams to voice their opinion? Who has a higher trade value or who would you rather take? Gaurantee you roddy crushes hill in that vote. Gms would vote the same way if given the choice between a rotation player or a potential star. I'd love for you to take me up on this offer
Because we all know players with less than a full season under their belt are always worth their projected value.well how about this. In a survey this summer when the gms were asked which international player they most expect to have a break out season, roddy garnered at least twice the amount of votes than anyone else...... And the mavs were also offered multiple top ten lotto picks for him. Good enough for you? Does it kill you to know the mavs might have a special talent on their hands? Obviously
Speaking of which, has anyone heard from Trajan Langdon lately?
how many big name, young international players are there? the fact that they picked isnt saying much, hardly anything to get excited about to the pt where you would proclaim him the next isiah thomas...link of the top ten lotto pick offers too tbh.
it doesnt kill me at all, i just find the hype around a guy that has logged 700 nba minutes pretty funny tbh
make the poll...exclude spur fans and mav fans from voting, including all mav krew trolls.
gms would take hill over roddy btw, thats obvious to anyone outside of dallas.
Except the small detail that the Mavs won't be able to get
It may have increased his price, it's done nothing to increase his value.
a significant upgrade via trade without Roddys name coming up and being included
Not worth talking to spurs fans about roddy, I've heard enough from other teams fans to know where roddy's trade value is, and it's way beyond that of George hill
It may have increased his price, it's done nothing to increase his value.
But not enough to land a Gerald Wallace, despite Roddy being the "future franchise" of the Mavs.
That's may be true, it also has nothing to do with point of my post. Roddy's value to other teams will be based on their estimate of what he can become as an NBA player, not the price tag Dallas attaches to him.
Not gonna waste my time researching links for you, don't really care enough. I asked you to ask another teams fan about roddy if you want an objective assessment. I get it, you don't believe me. So ask a blazers fan or something like that, our disagreement on the player isn't going anywhere
mavfan delusion is hilarious
Read your post that I quoted and try again. You said that Roddy's value was 'skyrocketing' because of what Dallas has said about him being 'untouchable'.
Because fans on message boards are great sources of objective opinions.
And obviously teams think he can be a heck of a player. When a team places a price tag of "future of the franchise" on a player, teams still make their own call, bit other teams become more intrigued and want to check him out. That's how his value has risen so quickly
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
