Rank the Point guards

[Killakobe81]

Well the way you make that Tim/David comparison, rings are relevant.



But in this discussion, we're having Paul vs. DWill vs. Rondo vs. Rose vs. Nash etc etc

The fact that Rondo won, does not boost him against another player like Paul, for example. If we remove Rondo and put CP3 on that team, does he win a championship? A resonating YES. what about Dwill? YES.

Does it give him points against the Rose argument? NO. Rose was not on that fully developed 2008 Celtics team.


Conclusion: Nothing.

That championship says nothing in this discussion.

Yep I agree. No argument. I have a personal ranking and one I am trying to decide here in this thread, by being objective as possible.
Again that is why I never brought up rings ...iniatially.
But for me it matters personally but Im trying to come to a more impersonal conclusion.
Read the first post again.

[Zelophehad]

Top 10:

CP3
Deron
Rose
Nash
Westbrook
Rondo
Parker
Billups
Curry
Felton/Andre Miller

[Pauleta14]

Did anybody looked at Westbrook's % shooting and TO????

He's great, no question, great upside... but right now? as a PG?

He's not in the top five...

1- CP3
2- DWill
3- Rose
4- Nash
5- Parker
6- Rondo
7- Westbrook

[buttsR4rebounding]

Did anybody looked at Westbrook's % shooting and TO????

He's great, no question, great upside... but right now? as a PG?

He's not in the top five...

1- CP3
2- DWill
3- Rose
4- Nash
5- Parker
6- Rondo
7- Westbrook

After watching Westbrook play over the weekend I would drop him down. He has been told by his coach to work on his lay ups. Judging from the Heat game he has a long way to go. Unless he got a dunk he just plain couldn't finish at the rim. In addition, he missed numerous open players for easy shots. There is no way he is a better point guard than Parker. He shoots almost 10% less from the field. His higher averages in points and assists are primarily from 2 reasons: 1. He plays more than 4 minutes a game more and 2 there are many times that Manu acts as point for the Spurs even when Parker is in the game. Westbrook has poor shot selection and court awareness.