sons who is better? Player A or Player B

[Giuseppe]

The goods seem spoiled and expired.

He got ya good. Big deal. It ain't the end of the world.

[badfish22]

Testify!!

[The Reckoning]

yeah i voted already but then realized ft % and ftm is huge. oops.

[Giuseppe]

lol ignorant and mad spurs fans with the "but but but!!! Manu plays less minutes! In full minutes he is just as effective as lebron!!! He is my hero don't talk bad about him!"

lol you idiots do realize that manu only plays 3 less minutes per game right? ... Its funny how when this argument comes up you only defend manu's side of it .... Well that doesn't make up for the fact that in less minutes manu -

1. Turns the ball over like crazy
2. Shoots a pathetic and ty percentage
3. Still can't rebound or block worth a damn

manu plays 32 minutes a game. Spurs fans you need a new excuse.

br

[ElNono]

lol ignorant and mad spurs fans with the "but but but!!! Manu plays less minutes! in full minutes he is JUST as effective as Lebron!!! he is my hero don't talk bad about him!"

lol you idiots do realize that Manu only plays 3 less minutes per game right? ... its funny how when this argument comes up you only defend Manu's side of it .... well that doesn't make up for the fact that in LESS MINUTES Manu -

1. Turns the ball over like crazy
2. Shoots a pathetic and ty percentage
3. still can't rebound or block worth a damn

Manu plays 32 minutes a game. Spurs fans you need a new excuse.

lol, why u mad?

Is it because West is not as good as Manu or because West is no better than Antawn Jamison?

[fevertrees]

[BRHornet45]

LOL at any Spurs fan who uses the "minutes" excuse. with Timmy its the same story ... "but...but...but.... if Timmy played 40 minutes he would still be like a 25 year old Kareem! don't talk about my hero that way!"

[Giuseppe]

Work that ass, BR!!!!

[it's me]

I bet this idiot would kill to pair Manu with CP3 lol

[Rummpd]

lol ignorant and mad spurs fans with the "but but but!!! Manu plays less minutes! in full minutes he is JUST as effective as Lebron!!! he is my hero don't talk bad about him!"

lol you idiots do realize that Manu only plays 3 less minutes per game right? ... its funny how when this argument comes up you only defend Manu's side of it .... well that doesn't make up for the fact that in LESS MINUTES Manu -

1. Turns the ball over like crazy
2. Shoots a pathetic and ty percentage
3. still can't rebound or block worth a damn

Manu plays 32 minutes a game. Spurs fans you need a new excuse.

And you my friend are ignorant of advanced stats (see above) - PER and the like as Manu/Parker and Duncan all exceed West - without Paul your team ain't *&^

There is NOT ONE GM in the leauge who would not trade for Manu and give up West if they are the same age - ignorant arguement. West is a stat machine some nights but you CANNOT compare positions!

Manu is FAR superior NBA player still than West. [B]Brilliant player and 3rd in the entire NBA in PER at his position! (and by the way was higher than Bryant last year in PER[)/B]
West is an average PF that is short, never won anything, and a mediocre defender that relies on Okafur to cover his ass = that is why no one cares about him period.

[BRHornet45]

lol, why u mad?

Is it because West is not as good as Manu or because West is no better than Antawn Jamison?

lol son you're the one getting mad about it. I mean after all, Manu's not even an All Star .... David West is twice

sorry buddy, but your great white hope is nothing more than balding, overrated trash. s of a person too.

[crc21209]

lol ignorant and mad spurs fans with the "but but but!!! Manu plays less minutes! in full minutes he is JUST as effective as Lebron!!! he is my hero don't talk bad about him!"

lol you idiots do realize that Manu only plays 3 less minutes per game right? ... its funny how when this argument comes up you only defend Manu's side of it .... well that doesn't make up for the fact that in LESS MINUTES Manu -

1. Turns the ball over like crazy
2. Shoots a pathetic and ty percentage
3. still can't rebound or block worth a damn

Manu plays 32 minutes a game. Spurs fans you need a new excuse.

1. Of course guards are going to turn over the ball more since they handle it more than a big man idiot.

2. Manu has won 3 les along side TP and TD, how many have Paul and West led their team to?

3. Guards arent really known for rebounding or blocking shots, seeing as they are out on the perimeter and thats more of a big man's job.

[BRHornet45]

And you my friend are ignorant of advanced stats (see above) - PER and the like as Manu/Parker and Duncan all exceed West - without Paul your team ain't *&^

There is NOT ONE GM in the leauge who would not trade for Manu and give up West if they are the same age - ignorant arguement. West is a stat machine some nights but you CANNOT compare positions!

not really ... Manu is just another role player on a good team in Pops system right now. the guy has been a solid bench player his entire career. nothing more, nothing less ... stop trying to put this guy up there with Kobe, Wade, and Lebron. Manu can't even lace up their shoes.

[Rummpd]

BR this is arguement you cannot win period. Manu is FIVE X the player of West period and so far more valuable whether by PER or any other method it not close.

[xellos88330]

lol son you're the one getting mad about it. I mean after all, Manu's not even an All Star .... David West is twice

sorry buddy, but your great white hope is nothing more than balding, overrated trash. s of a person too.

Ginobili has been an all star before.

[crc21209]

not really ... Manu is just another role player on a good team in Pops system right now. the guy has been a solid bench player his entire career. nothing more, nothing less ... stop trying to put this guy up there with Kobe, Wade, and Lebron. Manu can't even lace up their shoes.

And West wouldnt even be able to bend over to attempt to lace up Duncan's shoes because his weak ass back would give out again...

[Rummpd]

BR this is arguement you cannot win period. Manu is FIVE X the player of West period and so far more valuable whether by PER or any other method it not close.

B.S. on any other team Manu would be the star - you are losing touch with reality my friend. West is a fine player but he is the role player without Paul NO is a 30 win team tops. Put Manu with Paul and any half ass replacement for West and NO suddenly an instant le contender.

[ElNono]

lol son you're the one getting mad about it. I mean after all, Manu's not even an All Star .... David West is twice

Pretending not to be mad, then starting butthurt comparison threads omitting things like 3P% or FT%...

Manu is a 3x NBA champion, you think he gives a about All-Star?

sorry buddy, but your great white hope is nothing more than balding, overrated trash. s of a person too.

You sound really mad.
You still can't get over the fact that he viciously beat Capt West and CP3 in your house a couple of seasons ago?

Don't be mad, bro. West is Antawn Jamison nice!

[ElNono]

LOL at any Spurs fan who uses the "minutes" excuse. with Timmy its the same story ... "but...but...but.... if Timmy played 40 minutes he would still be like a 25 year old Kareem! don't talk about my hero that way!"

Son, how do you explain Antawn Jamison plays as many minutes as Capt West, shoots a much worse FG% yet puts up the same numbers?

[BRHornet45]

BR this is arguement you cannot win period. Manu is FIVE X the player of West period and so far more valuable whether by PER or any other method it not close.

LOL you can't truly believe yourself can you???? ... Manu is a BORDERLINE All Star this season dude. yet this is supposedly Manu's "year" as some have been saying. every NBA analyst and expert have Manu sitting on the bench for the All Star game this season .... he is not "5 X the player" that West is. They are relatively even and if you think otherwise you are a damn fool. West has far better career numbers than Manu .... by FAR .... just because Manu has been a role player and won 3 rings doesn't mean he is boosted up there with the greats.

LOL at these idiots thinking rings make all the players. Spurs fans truly believe this , yet they won't rank Horry up there with Jordan for some reason.

[Rummpd]

http://3behindthearc.blogspot.com/20...-shooting.html

Manu Ginobili and Dwyane Wade tied for the top spot. That's no surprise - they were one and two in the 2009-10 Final Shooting Guard Rankings. Wade is first in the PER and Estimated Wins Added categories while Ginobili leads the Simple Rating category.
Ray Allen and Kobe Bryant are on the second level. Allen moved up three spots from the 09-10 rankings while Bryant dropped one.



By some observations Manu is at the very top of the SGs in the league and right now is 3rd in PER - you my friend have started and arguement you CANNOT win!

[BRHornet45]

Son, how do you explain Antawn Jamison plays as many minutes as Capt West, shoots a much worse FG% yet puts up the same numbers?

the same way Monta Ellis rapes Manu .... more points, better shooter, etc.

[The Reckoning]

jamison is wrecking shop this year though...for being on such a ty team

[Brazil]

LOL at any Spurs fan who uses the "minutes" excuse. with Timmy its the same story ... "but...but...but.... if Timmy played 40 minutes he would still be like a 25 year old Kareem! don't talk about my hero that way!"

So lets see, Tim is old and washed up, Manu is a TO machine, shooting briks and clearly << D. West.

For the rest your opinion is (to sum up) West > Tim old and washed up, Okafor > whoever big the spurs have (lol undersized blair...), CP3 > TP, I'm sure you also consider Ariza > RJ and of course Marco Jordan Belenelililiililiiii >= Manu.

So why the hornets are not 40 - 7 ? honest question

[Rummpd]

BR you must have drank too much - I will be spending the weekend in New Orleans for the American Academy of Dermatology meeting - tell me where do find such good $#% there as you must be on something David FRIGGIN WEST COMPARED TO MANU HA HA HA!