Having a versatile voice is what they're after. Or should be after. Carrie has a versatile voice. Scotty doesn't. Apples to oranges. Her being a country star has no bearing on whether Scotty should go far. Like I said, picture him singing a Stevie Wonder tune. Nuff said.
Soooo, is this Rock-n-Roll American Idol? R&B American Idol? Oldies American Idol? No, it's AMERICAN IDOL! This show includes ALL TYPES OF MUSIC!
Just messing with you!
Right now I'm not a fan of anyone .....yet!I'm just a hater when it comes to country music.
Carrie Underwood might disagree with you.
I only saw part of it last night (the last four, I believe). I can't really say who is the best of them at this point.
Totally agree. Carrie can sing anything, but happens to sing country and sounds and looks amazing doing so
Scotty can ONLY sing country. Don't they have a show for that on CMT?
From everything I've read, they aren't making anyone sing out of their genre this year, so if that's really the case he wouldn't be singing a Stevie Wonder tune, so that'd be a moot point. Nuff said? WTF?
I never said I thought he was going to win (I don't, by a long shot), I just said I liked his voice if I closed my eyes when I listen to him. Because he reminds me of the MAD Magazine dude.
Totally agree. Carrie can sing anything, but happens to sing country and sounds and looks amazing doing so
Scotty can ONLY sing country. Don't they have a show for that on CMT?
If you have to ask, then the country show is either not around anymore or isn't popular.
I don't care what they say ... that first chick was terrrrrible. Yuck.
I agree. The only four girls that I liked tonight were Karen Rodriguez, Pia Toscano, Thia Megia and Ashton Jones.
The best singer of the guys is Jacob, while the most creative is easily Casey. The rest of the guys are just chasing those two, imo.
Also, Jordan was incredibly terrible. How some of them made it over Jaycee and Chris is beyond me.
The girls are a lot tougher to judge. I liked Karen tonight, but that's because I'm Hispanic so I'm biased towards her. Julie was one of my favorites because of her looks but she didn't do so hot tonight. Lauren Alaina, Thia, and Pia were the best of the night, along with Karen.
I miss Simon though, as it seems that Lopez and Tyler like every performance unless it's just downright bad. Even Randy said he'd be disagreeing with them most of the season.
and Hailey. I thought she was great.
Those are the ones I like, too. I like the young country-ish one, but she gets on my nerves a little too much.
I guess white people still don't like us Mexicans. DialIdol has Karen dead last.
If you like her, better vote for her. It's a shame because she might not be the best, but there's no way she's the worst, not even close.
My top 3 women:
1. Karen Rodriguez
2. Laurea Alaina
3. Lauren Turner
Over at American Idol.com several posters don't like her singing in spanish! A whole thread was deleted b/c of racial slurs and such!
Hopefully, if Karen is not in the Top 5, the judges will use her for their wild card picks because she definitely deserves to go on.
Randy is the new Simon, because J-Lo and Steven can't be honest and tell someone they suck.
My Top 3 Girls are:
Lauren Alaina, 16 yr old
Kendra
Naima - although I did agree with Randy that it sounded Loungeish.
I knew Randy would be. In fact, I think I may have posted that in here earlier. JLo sounds dumb at times but Tyler is kinda truthful at times. No girl really stood out for me. Some were good. Some not so good.Randy is the new Simon, because J-Lo and Steven can't be honest and tell someone they suck.
My Top 3 Girls are:
Lauren Alaina, 16 yr old
Kendra
Naima - although I did agree with Randy that it sounded Loungeish.
Most of the dudes just give me the creeps. The only ones I liked were Judas Priest, Rod Stewart and Screamin' Jay Hawkins.
The chicks are pretty hot this year. They were all pretty good, not great.
Your girl was horrible, sorry.
Yep. And I'm tired of the poodle skirts that she wears all the time. I hope she varies soon.Your girl was horrible, sorry.
The skirts are cute.
I know.
Thia, Pia, and Karen got that on lock. And the blonde girl that sang Christina Aguilera was pretty good too IMO.
The final 3 will be Thia, Pia, and Jacob!
I didn't think she was that good LAST NIGHT. She was smoking hot though.
That's a solid final 3, but I think I'd put Casey in there over one of the girls. Most likely Pia.
He's too talented not to make it deep into the compe ion. And I like his style.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
