Bynum or Duncan?

[DMC]

If I am starting a team now, can I select "none of the above"?

Duncan is 1 year from retirement and Bynum is 1 injury from retirement.

I will just take a rain check.

[The Refrigerator]

Lets see how many ways spurfan can come up with to dodge the question...

Duncan is still better defensively and a more proven compe or when it counts but Bynum has an incredible upside on both sides of the ball and if he stays healthy will be a great NBA center.

#1

Duncan would look a lot better with Odom/Gasol, instead of Bonner/Blair..

#2

Idk, I don't think Duncan's ever been shut down by Aaron Gray though js.

#3

Are we talking about knees or overall?

#4

Duncan led the Spurs to 4 rings, but he is now past his prime.

Bynum is still just a kid, with most of his career still in front of him.

Time will tell.

#5

the tired bag >>>> Gasol

#6

If I am starting a team now, can I select "none of the above"?

Duncan is 1 year from retirement and Bynum is 1 injury from retirement.

I will just take a rain check.

#7

#8

#9

[4>0rings]

Duncan on his death bed > Bynum

[ohmwrecker]

Duncan is obviously better than Bynum.

[LkrFan]

Duncan led the Spurs to 4 rings, but he is now past his prime.

Bynum is still just a kid, with most of his career still in front of him.

Time will tell.

The question was who is better not who was better (and had the better career). Quit pussy-footing around and answer the question, Spurfan.

[LkrFan]

Duncan would look a lot better with Odom/Gasol, instead of Bonner/Blair..

In other words, he needs someone to carry him. Answer the question, Spurfan: who is better right now?

[LkrFan]

The amount of "Duncan > Gasol " posts in this thread probably answers the OP's question.

[LkrFan]

Duncan is obviously better than Bynum.

In career achievement? No debates there.

But is Timmy D better right now? no and you know this, mannnn.

[fyatuk]

Duncan over Bynum, easy. Bynum's a better rebounder and probably a better on-man defender now, but Duncan is still more capable than Bynum in just about any other category.

Probably won't be true next year about this time if Bynum doesn't blow out a leg again.

[The Refrigerator]

Duncan is obviously better than Bynum.

Bynum
Points-11.3
Rebounds- 9.4
Blocks- 2.0
Fg%- .574


Duncan
Points- 13.4
Rebounds- 8.9
Blocks- 1.9
Fg% - .500


Yes, he is OBVIOUSLY better. Thats not a homer opinion at all. Bynum's fg% is 7% higher. *GASP* According to spurfan logic that means he is a better player! Or does that argument only work when we use it against Kobe? It's not convenient for spurfan right now so we'll just ignore it. Just like the free throw differential ing right spurfan?

[FkLA]

Duncan, even at his age, is and will always be a better player than Bynum.

[z0sa]

Duncan

[DMC]

Learn the difference between dodging a question and ignoring it.

[DMX7]

Today, Duncan.

[21_Blessings]

Duncan, even at his age, is and will always be a better player than Bynum.

Then why has Bynum dominated Duncan their last 3 matchups?

[4>0rings]

Bynum
Points-11.3
Rebounds- 9.4
Blocks- 2.0
Fg%- .574


Duncan
Points- 13.4
Rebounds- 8.9
Blocks- 1.9
Fg% - .500


Yes, he is OBVIOUSLY better. Thats not a homer opinion at all. Bynum's fg% is 7% higher. *GASP* According to spurfan logic that means he is a better player! Or does that argument only work when we use it against Kobe? It's not convenient for spurfan right now so we'll just ignore it. Just like the free throw differential ing right spurfan?

Even when Duncan's getting dirt tossed on his grave he's still better than Bynum.

[ginobili's bald spot]

Even when Duncan's getting dirt tossed on his grave he's still better than Bynum.

How far has Duncan fallen when spurfan is reduced to bragging about the best player in the history of their franchise being better than a role player.

[Hoops Czar]

lets see how many ways spurfan can come up with to dodge the question...











#1




#2




#3






#4



#5







#6






#7









#8




#9

duncan on his death bed > bynum

#10

duncan is obviously better than bynum.

#11

duncan over bynum, easy. Bynum's a better rebounder and probably a better on-man defender now, but duncan is still more capable than bynum in just about any other category.


Probably won't be true next year about this time if bynum doesn't blow out a leg again.

#12 - Completely off-the-wall delusional

duncan, even at his age, is and will always be a better player than bynum.

#13

today, duncan.

#14

What did you really expect in a Spurs forum? If you said Neal/Bryant, they would have made a case for Neal.

I'm not sure why you'd bait Spurs Fans. You know the answer, yet, you know the answer your going to get.

[DMC]

Ask Bynum.

[The Refrigerator]

How has Duncan done in his matchups against Bynum this season? Can a spurfan fill me in on what his averages were? Since he's so much batter I'm sure they are amazing.

[Chieflion]

Since Bynum is so much better than Duncan, I expect the Lakers to sweep the Spurs if they meet in the WCF. If they even lose one game, it would be such a disgrace.

[Hoops Czar]

Since Bynum is so much better than Duncan, I expect the Lakers to sweep the Spurs if they meet in the WCF. If they even lose one game, it would be such a disgrace.

With that logic, Dwight Howard should be a shoe in to win the championship this year.

[4>0rings]

Bynum: 2

Duncan: 4

[Giuseppe]

Since Bynum is so much better than Duncan, I expect the Lakers to sweep the Spurs if they meet in the WCF. If they even lose one game, it would be such a disgrace.

Chief, gettin' his insulation on. Ya pussy, you.

[LkrFan]

Bynum: 2 in only 6 years. 23 years old and is on the upside of his career. Won't reach prime for 2-3 more years.

Duncan: 4 in 14 years. 35 years old and on the downside of his career. Past prime for 2-3 years.

FIFY to give perspective. No thanks necessary.