Eli Manning says he's "In the same class as Tom Brady"

[symple19]

http://espn.go.com/newyork/hot/?id=6870256

[DUNCANownsKOBE]

Timmy2Zo forum or whatever that guys name is

[DeadlyDynasty]

in before TimmytoZo's analysis

[DeadlyDynasty]

Timmy2Zo forum or whatever that guys name is

er beat me to it

[symple19]

lol, can't wait to see what that dude(troll) has to say about this

[Monostradamus]

to be fair, since 2005...

Eli 1
Brady 0

[Fabbs]

to be fair, since no cameras...

Eli 1
Brady 0

concur

[lefty]

[Monostradamus]

i like to change quotes

[Fabbs]

I try to stop facts from being jammed up my arse as regards TommDoll and the PattyCakes. And I fail.

There there Monnie.....

[Bill_Brasky]

Would a top 5 QB miss the playoffs?

[Spursfan092120]

Little late, obsessed boy.

http://www.spurstalk.com/forums/show...8&postcount=78

His reaction

http://www.spurstalk.com/forums/show...4&postcount=80

[TIMMYtoZO]

I don't see how any of this is funny. Eli outplayed Brady in the superbowl especially in crunch time. Look, Eli Manning is an elite qb. Outside of his brother and Brady, there isn't a qb better than Eli. Now there are some that aren't that far from him I will admit (Rodgers,Brees, and possibly Big Ben), but the rest are further down.

[symple19]

He's not even top 5

Aaron Rodgers, Big Ben, Vick, Brees, Rivers, Peyton, Brady, and Matt Ryan are all better QB's (in no particular order)

I would put him at #9

[LakerHater]

Eli should jus STFU!
Even us Giants fans know he isnt "elite"!

[symple19]

Eli should jus STFU!
Even us Giants fans know he isnt "elite"!

The Niners would take him if you guys wanna trade, though

[LakerHater]

The Niners would take him if you guys wanna trade, though

Im sure they would!! Reese woulndt part with'em though!

I'm fine with Eli as our QB but, I would not put him in the "elite" status yet. I still think you have the top 3 in Peyton, Brady and Brees. Eli would fall into the next tier of QBs that are very good, just not elite.

[Dirk Nowitzki]

Im sure they would!! Reese woulndt part with'em though!

I'm fine with Eli as our QB but, I would not put him in the "elite" status yet. I still think you have the top 3 in Peyton, Brady and Brees. Eli would fall into the next tier of QBs that are very good, just not elite.

Ummmmmmm Aaron Rodgers is part of that elite class now. Brady/Manning are on the super elite level. Rodgers and Brees are part of just the regular elite. Rodgers>>>>>>>>>>>Eli and it isn't close at all.

[spursreport]

Im sure they would!! Reese woulndt part with'em though!

I'm fine with Eli as our QB but, I would not put him in the "elite" status yet. I still think you have the top 3 in Peyton, Brady and Brees. Eli would fall into the next tier of QBs that are very good, just not elite.

Wow. Another ing re ed take by a dumbass Giants fan. Why isn't Aaron Rodgers isn't in this list? Eli is well below Rodgers. Rivers is better than Eli as well. Don't ever put Eli in the class of those 2. Good grief.

[TE]

[LakerHater]

Wow. Another ing re ed take by a dumbass Giants fan. Why isn't Aaron Rodgers isn't in this list? Eli is well below Rodgers. Rivers is better than Eli as well. Don't ever put Eli in the class of those 2. Good grief.

Did you not read what I worte, in re !?? Did you not read what I wrote in post #15??
You can put Rodgers, Rivers, even Vick on the list!! I jus named the top 3, I didnt put out a "List"...STUPID !!!

[LnGrrrR]

Wow, TimmytoZo has re ed takes in two sports. Timmy, do you follow other sports? Do you think that the Penguins will overcome either the Yanks or Sox? What about hockey? Do you think the Thrashers can go all the way?

[spursreport]

Did you not read what I worte, in re !?? Did you not read what I wrote in post #15??
You can put Rodgers, Rivers, even Vick on the list!! I jus named the top 3, I didnt put out a "List"...STUPID !!!

Rodgers is right there with Brees you dumb son of a . My god you are a ing moron.

[Spursfan092120]

Rodgers is right there with Brees you dumb son of a .

[lefty]

Bump

Loli

Elol