I'd rather people not be dumbasses that resort to physical violence for something as idiotic as someone showing off. In fact, I'm all for making it a lifetime ban from football for whomever does it.
I've only seen a shortened version of this video maybe 10 years ago.![]()
I'd rather people not be dumbasses that resort to physical violence for something as idiotic as someone showing off. In fact, I'm all for making it a lifetime ban from football for whomever does it.
I'm not talking about the video ofcourse, I'm saying Neymar doesn't deserve to be physically injured because he likes to showboat. Showboating is part of the game, being a violent re that gets upset because other people are better than him is not.
"Violence is the last refuge of the incompetent."
* Isaac Asimov, Foundation
Violence is not only physical. Winding up someone is as violent as throwing a punch in retaliation.
Wasn't Materazzi violent calling Zidane's sister all sorts of stuff?
And while I do agree that a punch might be going overboard, football nowadays is too watered down. Everything is a foul, specially in the Brazilian league. Players dive all the time, even when there's no contact because they know the refs will bail them out. If current players had to deal with how football was played in the 60's, 70's and 80's they would leave the pitch crying after 5 minutes.
That's one thing I like about MLS. There is much less diving in MLS compared to other leagues around the world.
hence why I specified "physical violence"
However, verbal violence and physical violence aren't equally as egregious now are they? calling someone's mom a isn't on the same level as physically assaulting them.Wasn't Materazzi violent calling Zidane's sister all sorts of stuff?
I think we can all agree the diving in football has become a ing joke. That still doesn't justify hitting or injuring someone because he/she made you look bad whether it be necessary or not.And while I do agree that a punch might be going overboard, football nowadays is too watered down. Everything is a foul, specially in the Brazilian league. Players dive all the time, even when there's no contact because they know the refs will bail them out. If current players had to deal with how football was played in the 60's, 70's and 80's they would leave the pitch crying after 5 minutes.
Again, I agree the diving has become ridiculous, but I don't necessarily agree that going back to the violence in football during those decades you mentioned is a good thing either.
doesn't deserve? does his opponent deserve to be taunted? I'm not talking about pulling some fancy dribble, I'm talking about waiting with your hands on your hips and doing stationary step overs. Deserve has nothing to do with it.
Saying that showboating is part of the game is just as helpful as saying cheapshots are part of the game.
Bottomline is that some players like to do that even if it doesnt help the team win, and those players nearly always, in any league, get hit, either from a "legal" challenge or a cheapshot like in the video MMLH posted.
are you equating showboating with hitting someone on the face??
I'm sorry, but I find your way of thinking completely idiotic. If a player has the ability to do something on the field in terms of the game of football then he has the right to try and do it. I don't give a how it makes the player in front of him feel when he's unable to stop him.
Give me a ing break! I don't particularly enjoy when a player that is more skilled than me at football does a fancy trick and leaves me wondering what the happened, but I'm not about to resort to tackling him or punching him in the face for having done it, no matter what the ing score is.
Its a completely ridiculous notion, and one that has no place in the sport.
Like I said, I'm a big proponent of enacting bans for those sorts of at udes. Gradually increasing in severity in terms of the severity of the action of course, but a ban nonetheless.
I don't like to see players showboating but I dislike more those emotional re ed scrubs that have to resort to hitting because they can't get the ball back.
You don't like to get "showboated" get the ball back and don't lose and if you can't, keep trying.
Hitting is for pussies.
tbh in world cup play Neymar/Messi are pretty even.
Pele is probably just concentrating on world cup play. You know, the playoffs of soccer.
guys like Pele are like Jordan, you haven't won in the playoffs, you don't belong in the conversation.![]()
When a player like messi dribbles past three defenders and chips the keeper, he doesnt give anyone stares or come down the next time acting like he is unguardable. he just makes his plays and keeps going. same with manu- at the most he might get a little excited and fist pump, but he is not going to be petulant with his opponent or start looking for the cameras. when these guys get hit, its because their opponent is frustrated and that is wrong, but understandable to a degree, with the degree being how legit the attempt to recover / stop the play was.
when a guy like neymar dribbles past three defenders and chips the keeper, he gives everyone his stare down, starts dancing and shining his shoe and winking at the camera, he is showing up his opponent. same with say blake griffin now. rightly or wrongly, in the history of sport those guys get hit with a different kind of prejudice than the others do. they all get hit, make no mistake, but the showboating, taunting types always get hit more, either by cheapshots or "legit" hard tackles. and I believe it is warranted, because there is no reason to be a little just because you are better.
and to be clear, I dont have a problem with Neymar's dribble in that vid; it's a nice dribble, even if it doesnt particularly get him anywhere. the problem for me is before the defender gets there and he's got his arms on his hips, those little one footed stepovers that only serve to mock the defender. the only way you can argue that being necessary is the psychological effect on the other player, but to me that is provocation just like Materazzi talking or Van Bommel feeling people up on a corner kick, it has nothing to do with skill and all about lack of class.
The way you make it sound, you are ok with say Ricky Davis shooting at his own basket for an extra rebound- there's no rule against it right? I'm pretty sure there are rules against taunting in both footie and basketball, but those rules are never applied evenly and less for a superstar like Neymar.
one thing is for a guy to nutmeg you or lob it over you etc etc etc, another is for that guy to tease you before / after doing it. If you can't tell that Neymar is doing that here, then I guess you don't play much.
wake me up when Messi does this in the Playoffs, I mean the World cup
Based God
Jason Williams
only 20 years old
Brazilian league
Smoke and mirrors
the next Robinho
hasn't done with national team
Brazilians desperately needing to hype someone for their World Cup
flat-track bully
How ironic.![]()
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)