RGIII is good. Luck is just better. He has tripled his team's win total with 6 games left to play while the Skins' record was only one game worse a year ago than it is now.
No doubt RG3 is really good...but will teams eventually figure how to gameplan for him?
RGIII is good. Luck is just better. He has tripled his team's win total with 6 games left to play while the Skins' record was only one game worse a year ago than it is now.
I agree. Luck will probably be in his first AFC Championship Game, and RG3 will be rehabbing after his 2nd or 3rd ankle/knee injury from thinking that scrambling in the NFL will equal a long & successful career.
Premature thread is premature.
Cam Newton put up huge numbers last year for a losing team as well.
Lets not forget Peyton Mannings rookie season either.
We will know who truly is the better QB in a couple of years, and my money is on Luck and the Colts
As of right now if this were a fight they'd pull RGIII off Andre Luck, he's killing him. Not even close!
All you dummies with your..."QB is a white position"....must have grown up weird.
A black QB will be playing for a national championship when ND meets some SEC stud. Black QB's have won the last two Heismans. That gang of Moon, McNabb, McNair and Cunningham are listed in on all those all time stat lists.
Never seen so many who know so little, amazing!
Last edited by Avante; 11-25-2012 at 05:23 AM.
Everett Golson isn't exactly the reason ND is in the le game, sorry senor!
Well their white QB rides the bench.
Can you go further into detail about Golson willing ND to the le game?
I can talk about how his ability to run sure beats the out of slow whitey who can't. Teams are wanting athletes back there, guys who can extend a play.
Luck at least 10 season career, RG3 will probably be knocked out next year.
There your stupid fatass goes again, bringing up gimmicky college QBs in the NFL forum.
Don't understand this reasoning. Vick, McNabb, ect. been in the nfl for a lot of years.
The argument that RGIII will be out of the NFL in a few years doesn't make sense, I agree.
The argument that would make a lot more sense is he'll miss games every year because of injuries, which is what happened with Vick and McNabb.
yea that made absolutely no sense.
I've watched more of RG3 than Luck, and IMO the Redskins receiving corps is inconsistent. They make some great catches (e.g. Garcon in the last game) but also drop catchable passes frequently. DOK, I'd rather point to the difference between Washington and Indy's running backs than receivers. The threat of Alfred Morris helps RG3 significantly, teams that play Indy can focus a lot more on shutting down Luck.
Luck and Griffin sure as look a lot better than Russell ing Wilson.
There goes another one of your horrible takes
Luck will be making deep playoff runs for years to come. During that time, RG3 will be at home rehabbing his injuries and watching Luck on television.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)