Reply With Quote
No way in RGIII out played RW.
What do we judge QB's by, yep...playoffs.
Leaking all over twitter. Congrats on a great season, playoff berth, get healthy !
Looking at his stats I noticed he had more rushing yards this year than any year in college. They need to cut that down because he is not durable
No way in RGIII out played RW.
What do we judge QB's by, yep...playoffs.
Is mark Sanchez better than Matt ryan
Is Tom Brady better than Mark Sanchez?
Anyone who thinks RGIII had a better rookie season than RW is crazy, he didn't! RW came within a FG of playing in the conference le game, we ignore that?
Yes because Brady has rings and more wins. Sanchez has been to more CCG and has more playoff wins than Matt Ryan. Ryan has had more offensive talent around him as well so by your logic Sanchez>ryan
Actually my logic is when we see a rookie do what RW did in the playoffs vs what RGIII didn't do it's real easy to see who was the better rookie. RW had the better season by far. , the guy tied the rookie QB TD record, won a playoff game, then did what we saw yesterday, what did RGIII do to compare to that? Yep. nothing!
I saw that he couldn't manage the clock properly and piss away 3 points right before the half that would ultimately cost them the game.
Congrats to RGIII. He had a great season. Hope he gets healthy!
We also saw him beat RGIII, beat up the Niners, beat The Pats...our two SB teams. Throw as many TD's as any rookie in history, and play one of the best games ever played by a rookie yesterday. Now tell me what did RGIII do to top that?
Did we see him miss any games like RGIII?
Last edited by Avante; 01-14-2013 at 07:05 PM.
He deserves it he won his division and didn't need a bull win to get into the playoffs
No he doesn't. He was outplayed and we all saw it. Don't forget he needed his back up to bail him out, we can't say that about RW.
So let's see...
Real close stat wise.
Head to head it was RW
Playoff success...RW
Rookie records....RW
Seems pretty simple to me.
Those awards go by season performance, not post-season.
Avante
RG3 deserves it, can't wait to see him go Adrian Peterson on this league when his knee heals up
So forget the fact RW beat both the Niners/Pats and threw for more TD's. So RW could have won the SB and RGIII be the rookie of the year...hahahaha!!!!!!!!!
Looks like I will be getting some money from a certain Jew soon.
I'm not wrong at all, couldn't be more right. How many playoff teams did RGIII beat? How about RW?
RG3 deserves it, can't wait to see him go Adrian Peterson on this league when his knee heals up
Do you really think RGIII had the more impressive season?
Who has a better RB? better Oline? better WR's? better D??
i think it's funny you talk about RG3 needing to get bailed out by his back up, yet RW got bailed out by the refs and there's no mention of that.
Well actually RGIII had the better RB. RGIII also had the better WR's. So about even there.
So tell me what did RGIII do that over shadowed RW beating both the Niners/Pats and his playtoff exploits.
It's incredible that a self-proclaimed NFL "expert" such as yourself has no idea that these awards only take into account the regular season...
I got to be honest I never ever thought about it. I never cared.
Well there is no doubt who had the better season, we all saw it. It's funny however, so RW could have won the SB but RGIII......
So who do you think we end up the best of the three?
If it's true, PM me your paypal info Creepn.
Talk about bull , wow!!!!!!!
Either the Niners or the Pats are going to win the SB, RW beat both of them. When was the last time a rookie QB beat both SB teams in a season, has it ever happened before?
LMAO! you are seriously a moron if you think Morris is better than Lynch. Not only did Lynch average more per carry, he's an established back that teams game plan for. Morris is a product of teams being so afraid of RG3's running ability. Don't believe me look at his ypc in the game that Griffin missed.
RG3 was without a very good TE in Fred Davis for the entire year, Pierre Garcon missed 6 games and was constantly banged up. Beyond that he had old as dirt Santana Moss, and castoff from SF Morgan. Wilson had Miller, former Pro bowler Rice, Baldwin who put up very nice numbers with Tavarvis Jackson, and a good young speedster in Tate....again you are truly stupid if you believe his Griffins supporting cast was better.
RG3 only won the division that featured last year's world champs, and he would've swept them if his secondary didn't suck ass (meanwhile RW gets the benefit of the best secondary in the league)
Obviously Lynch has the bigger rep being that Morris was a rookie but the rookie did score more TD's and gain more yards. It was close.
I'd forgotten about Garcon being injured, my bad.
The bottom line is that RW beat more quality teams, had more TD's. If the playoffs counted it would have been a no contest, RW easily.
Who do you think had the better seasoned? Remember RW never missed a game and did totally outdo RGIII on the playoffs.
Well, it's settled then... congrats to either the Ravens or the Falcons on their Super Bowl victory...
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
