Better solo artist: Peter Gabriel or Phil Collins?

[Blake]

Mike Rutherford.











Ok,ok. PG. Sledgehammer ftw.

Mike would need a miracle to be the best of the three

[DeadlyDynasty]

rimshot

[Bigzax]

this wouldn't even be a contest except for that damn boombox.

[cantthinkofanything]

How can you say Collins is a better singer than Gabriel? I know it's not quantifiable and is opinion, but Gabriel's voice is unique. I've never heard another like it. Listen to Red Rain and Shock the Monkey for dynamism, or In Your Eyes, Book of Love, or I Grieve for on-point singing.

I figure if Gabriel has anything on Collins it's voice and its use.

Gotye sounds like PG on dat song on da radio tbh.

[Blake]

rimshot

yessir.

I used to avoid cheesy lefty one liners, but I don't care any more. I don't care any more.

[Agloco]

phil, although pete gets the nod in the vocals category.

[Viva Las Espuelas]

they're both good but pc has more mainstream appeal. i think his better moments were when he actually played the drums with Brand X.

[exstatic]

I like PG, and respect his musical ability, but find him a bit pretentious. What's with naming each of your first three albums Peter Gabriel? Are you the George Foreman of music?

[mojorizen7]

Voted Phil. I prefer Gabriel's music,but he's got a niche....and i dig his niche.
Collins can do it all and he has.
If this poll would have called for my favorite then its Peter Gabriel.