Vince Young or Johnny Manziel?

[benefactor]

Which player is your starting QB if you are starting a college team?

[Spursfan092120]

This was a tough one...but I went with Vince. He played against tougher compe ion and was more dominant. Come to think about it...it's really not that tough. It's Vince...period.

[Sisk]

Johnny. Better passer and a more elusive runner.

[ThePop]

So, it depends. If I pick Johnny, does he come with Mike Evans? If not, I choose Vince.

[Sisk]

So, it depends. If I pick Johnny, does he come with Mike Evans? If not, I choose Vince.

I will agree with this. Would definitely be interested to see how Johnny would be without Mike, but I definitely do not want to see it happen.

[benefactor]

Vince beat not one, but two top five teams on their home turf in the same season. Pretty legendary feat.

I'll take Vince.

[Sisk]

So would you consider AJ McCarron then? He beat #5 LSU and #1 Notre Dame last year. Neither at home.

[DesignatedT]

Manziel. Give Manziel an average defense this year and he has a National Championship also.

[DesignatedT]

Tickets were allotted 50/50 in that Texas/USC game. Stop saying you beat 2 top 5 teams on the road. Doesn't work that way.

Manziel beat the National Champion on the road in front of 100k of their fans. That's a legendary feat. Not to mention he did it as a freshman and not a junior.

[Phillip]

Manziel. Give Manziel an average defense this year and he has a National Championship also.

lol take Evans away from Johnny and he isn't even in consideration for heisman this year, defense or not

[Blake]

Lol Vince

[Vito Corleone]

2k5 Ohio state had one of the top defenses I've ever seen. Vince owned them. Vince hands down was the most dominate player in 2k5.

Now if Manziel stayed for his junior year or his senior year I might actually pick Manziel, but his one signature win was against a sleeping Alabama team. As great as he is, I would still take Vince in a skinny second.

[DesignatedT]

Vince was a beast no doubt. He was physically too much to handle for college defenders. Manziel is a much better QB though when it comes to skills. He will prove that in the NFL.

[Phillip]

Vince was a beast no doubt. He was physically too much to handle for college defenders. Manziel is a much better QB though when it comes to skills. He will prove that in the NFL.

HAHAHAHAHA no.

[Sisk]

HAHAHAHAHA no.

I would love to make a ban bet with you that Johnny will have a better NFL career than Vince. Of course, that will take a year or two. But it would be the easiest bet I have ever won.

[Phillip]

I would love to make a ban bet with you that Johnny will have a better NFL career than Vince. Of course, that will take a year or two. But it would be the easiest bet I have ever won.

hm... offensive ROY, 2x pro bowl, 2 playoff appearances, 13 game winning drives and 7 4th quarter comebacks, winning record over his career

ill take that bet

[Robz4000]

Vince and it's not close.

[ThePop]

In order for that bet to be fair Johnny will have to be drafted by the Rams.

[benefactor]

So would you consider AJ McCarron then? He beat #5 LSU and #1 Notre Dame last year. Neither at home.

....

[Sisk]

....

Yeah, basing your choice off of wins is a bit ridiculous.

[DesignatedT]

vince' nfl career.

[Phillip]

Yeah, basing your choice off of wins is a bit ridiculous.

so winning isnt important?

[Phillip]

vince' nfl career.

johnny bound to actually be worse in the NFL than vince

[DesignatedT]

lol bound

[dirk4mvp]

johnny bound to actually be worse in the NFL than vince

All he really has to do to match VY's nfl career is have someone take shirtless photos of him and Justin Blackmon in da club next year.