Reply With Quote
Luck has made some absolutely terrible throws this year, but he's still playing like a top 5 QB.
Ill wait to pass judgement until the next 4 Games against the Ravens, Texans, tsburgh, and the Bengals.
I'll still give Brees the benefit of the doubt because he was terrific last year. He has looked shaky this year, but it's still early and could just be a rough start. Brady, while still great for moments or maybe a game at a time, hasn't been elite since 2012. He was good last year, but he wasn't in the Manning/Brees/Rodgers class. It could also be attributed to a lack of weapons
Luck has made some absolutely terrible throws this year, but he's still playing like a top 5 QB.
Ill wait to pass judgement until the next 4 Games against the Ravens, Texans, tsburgh, and the Bengals.
as great as luck is, he still just misses throws for no reason. his accuracy isn't like prime brady/manning
shocked how many Niner fans have Young as their favorite player. i just can't put him ahead Montana, Rice or even Lott, but that's me.
agree with this, especially about Luck. I might still put Manning above Rodgers just for old times sake, but no doubt Rodgers is in his prime and can make certain types of throws that Manning can't, though Manning's arm looks better than 2008-2011.
Favorite doesn't mean best. And most of us didn't see Montana or Lott in their prime.
even as a favorite, Young just didn't have the grace or coolness of Montana. but if you didn't grow up with them, that's understandable.
Wilson is elite right now. I'm amazed that even some Seahawks fans don't realize this yet. He's going to be known as one of the best ever.
I still rather have Luck. But the gap is closing.
not really. luck has been widening the gap this year
Luck would already be a SB champion if he played on the Bengals. Their roster is so ridiculously stacked in all facets that they're a big- QB away from ting on the league for years
Luck is a great QB, but so is Wilson. They are both great leaders which I think is one of the most important aspects of that position.
What the...?
Eesh. That's a pretty tough lineup. Indy could lose each of those games.
Eh, Lewis is still their coach.
lol dumping alex smith for kraep because he's more atlhetic
nah i wouldn't say he's the best just yet, but he is very talented and one of the best dual threat qb's in the league. he needs to chill out on the INT's, though.
He was actually very good on the INT's last year, but you also have to remember he gets faced with a lot of 3rd and longs thanks to Richardson/forced ground game as JT alluded to.
i think the GM and owner are at fault more than the coaches for the trent richardson debacle. they're just playing the hand that was dealt to them. not the coaches fault they have to give that scrub touches.
yea he did improve last year, i give him credit for that.
For the trade, yeah that's more on the GM but Pagano needs to chill out on the "we're a power running team" nonsense. The Colts don't have the personnel to play that way. Honestly the best thing for them would be to give Luck the Peyton Manning No-Huddle Playbook and start doing that.
Not according to his stats.
pep hamilton ed him over pretty bad last year
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
