Reply With Quote
Looks about right.
1. Aaron Rodgers
2. Drew Brees
3. Matt Ryan
4. Matthew Stafford
5. Tony Romo
6. Eli Manning
7. Nick Foles
8. Carson Palmer
9. Jay Cutler
10. Colin Kaepernick
11. Russell Wilson
12. Cam Newton
13. Mike Glennon
14. Cousins/McCoy
15. Austin Davis
16. Teddy Bridgewater
Looks about right.
Matthew Stafford and Krap are too high imo. Maybe Matthew Stafford behind Foles and Krap behind Glennon tbh
1. Aaron Rodgers
2. Drew Brees
3. Tony Romo
4. Russell Wison
5. Matthew Stafford
6. Matt Ryan
7. Eli Manning
8. Carson Palmer
9. Nick Foles
10. Colin Kaepernick
11. Jay Cutler
12. Cam Newton
13. Mike Glennon
14. Cousins/McCoy
15. Austin Davis
16. Teddy Bridgewater
Not that that can't change other than Rodgers and Brees.
Stafford may be ranked too high, but I give him props for being a gamer while missing some huge pieces. Romo and Palmer may be ranked too low, but I'm factoring in their inevitable facepalm games that'll surface at some point
I would put Romo 3rd. He's better than Ryan or Stafford. I would put Wilson over Kaep and probably over Cutler who sucks. Don't know where Foles fits in. He's not nearly as good as last season.
brees
rodgers
romo
no one else is worth mentioning
I actually like your list.
Why wouldn't you?
The Top 10
1.Peyton Manning
2.Aaron Rodgers
3.Tom Brady
4.Drew Brees
5.Big Ben
6.Philip Rivers
7.Tony Romo
8.Russell Wilson
9.Andrew Luck
10.Matthew Stafford
Last edited by Avante; 10-27-2014 at 01:24 AM.
1. Rodgers - he can just make some disgusting throws that nobody else in the NFL can. had an off game today
2. Brees - was money today, hasn't had a phenomenal season, but the NFC QB crop isn't that great, so he's still pretty safe here
3. Romo - he's thrived in the run/action offense. less responsibility, less mistakes. has basically been a better Wilson this year, albeit with better weapons
4. Wilson - his performance against Dallas has been overblown, as if it represents his body of work. has had a solid season, but he's going to need to play better
5. Palmer - poor overall game today, but still has one of the best deep balls in the NFL. arizona is a different team when the bomb is a threat
6. Eli - i'm still not buying it. i think he's a guy who's legacy will overestimate him, but he's played well in the last month with a limited offense around him
7. Ryan - everybody expected a big bounce-back year with Jones back, and their pass offense has disappointed. he's criminally underrated as a last minute of the game QB. one of the best
8. Stafford - predictably has been mediocre with his cheat code WR on the shelf, and its not like they have no other legit receivers. he's not that accurate and doesn't make good reads
9. Foles - most inconsistent QB in the conference. looks like a big time franchise guy one game, looks like a middling talent the next game. its also likely his offense inflates him
this is my cutoff from guys i like to guys i dont like. the teams above this list should be satisfied with their QB, the teams below should look to improve
10. Kaep - impressed against St. Louis, but that was St. Louis. i just dont have faith in his ability to drop back and release the ball with timing
11. Cutler - i'm a personal fan of his, but he's played like dog for most of this year. lazy mechanics have regressed. having great weapons made him lazy as far as making reads too
12. Newton - he's disappointed this year. i had him > Kaep going in. Benjamin and Olsen are legit targets, but he's just slow with decisions, inaccurate
13. Austin Davis - not that accurate, but the kid has huevos. he has the "compe or" thing going for him. he's a good backup QB who can come in and make plays, not a starter
14. Mike Glennon - he's more accurate than Davis but he plays without balls. he plays scared
15. McCoy - just bad. no timing, noodle arm. he's aggressive, which can be cool, but he makes decisions that his arm can't deliver
16. Bridgewater - he looks like he should be redshirting. is really hesitant, doesn't make decisions. not getting sacked/picked is a success for him
Short memories up here. Up until two games ago, Newton was having his best passing year ever. I guess a loss to Seattle does that to you (lol)
at Kaep >
Palmer is vastly underrated for a few reasons:
1. People still see him as interception-prone. While he still tries to fit the ball in to right windows every now and then, he's much better at finding the open man or check down. He has only one interception on the year, and it came off a tip drill.
2. People see his low completion percentage and assume bad throws. While yesterday he missed a few, three misses were Floyd incomprehensibly dropping a TD and two other passes, and 8-10 others were deliberate incompletes to avoid a sack. He's showing incredible judgment on where, when, and who gets the ball.
3. He doesn't have mind-blowing numbers. But he has an efficient 2-TD per average, factor with stronger running game, and he's a ridiculously dangerous QB who has helped Arizona lead NFL in plays over 30 yards thus far (or some stat like it). He makes good decisions and Cardinal drives typically control tempo and clock.
Fact is, in his last 13 games as a Cardinal he has 24 TDs and just 10 INTs, and the Cardinals are 12-2 in those games with wins at Seattle, and over Indy, Philly, Chargers. Maybe not the hardest schedule, but factor in a second Philly game and Denver game on the road, and two 49ers home games and the 14-3 in their last 17 games is pretty damned impressive.
A huge bit of credit going to Palmer no longer having a 1-1 TD/INT ratio, but a 2.4/1.
I'd have him 6th.
1. Rodgers
2. Brees
3. Wilson
4. Foles
5. Romo
6. Palmer
7. Newton
8. Stafford
9. Kaepernick
10. Ryan
11. Manning
12. Cutler
13. Washington QBs
14. St. Louis QBs
15. Minnesota QBs
16. Tampa Bay QBs
But I'm not just looking at stats, but records, and whom and how they beat their opponents.
no he isn't. Never been, never will.
Please enlighten us on why you think Stafford and Ryan are better than Romo at this point?
Rodgers
Brees
Romo
Ryan isn't better than Romo tbh
Rodgers way way ahead.
Brees
Pickem.
McAllah
The rest
EDIT: put McCoy over Newton now
Romo > Breesy tbh
are you some re ed kid? you still haven't proved my point on why Ryan or Stafford are better than Romo this season. No wonder some people call you a woman
Wheres Tom Brady?
Where's Tom Brady?
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
