Reply With Quote
Best of all-time from a longevity/career standpoint, tbh..
Although if Rodgers miraculously wins this year, he's the best of all-time from a peak perspective IMO..
Where does he rank in the all time QB list? Top 2 at minimum I think.. he would've been stapled at #1 if he got it done on the 18-1 season.
Best of all-time from a longevity/career standpoint, tbh..
Although if Rodgers miraculously wins this year, he's the best of all-time from a peak perspective IMO..
Montana is still head-and-shoulders above him and Rodgers, though Rodgers can still surpass him.
Tom Brady
Playoff record: 19-8
Home playoff record: 13-3
Road playoff record: 3-3
Super Bowl starts: 5
Super Bowl rings: 3
Joe Montana
Playoff record: 16-7
Home playoff record: 10-2
Road playoff record: 2-5
Super Bowl starts: 4
Super Bowl rings: 4
He's not beating Rodgers. Their D-Line has no shot containing Wilson. They may get to the SB but they won't win. I just hope they don't get a shank up their gooch like Manning last season.
^^Belichick would be much better prepared than ing John Fox, tbh..
How do the Patriots generally do vs. mobile QBs?
Packers aren't winning and there's no way Belichick loses to a negro QB, tbh.. He's going to have that team ready unlike John Fox last year..
begrudgingly, i'd pick the Pats to beat the Packers if they matched up
Seahawks Pats would be a ing great superbowl though.
Dude I swear I didn't steal your comment^^Belichick would be much better prepared than ing John Fox, tbh
Team accomplishments imo. When thinking about it, they both come from very similar backgrounds:
1. Both played under great coaches
2. Both had great longevity
3. Both delivered similar stats
The main reason I put Joe Cool over Brady is because he just seemed to have the "IT" factor. He could rally his team in any situation and get their nerved in check. Brady, OTOH, has notoriously chimped out in the past and has needed to be calmed down. There's also the whole system babby issue, which could be said about Joe, but in the end he went out and continued playing well on another team.
I'd still take Montana over him any day of the week. If Brady wins I could see the media anoint him GOAT but I'd place him in top 5. I still haven't seen an iconic performance by him in the SB, plus hasn't won post Viniatieri and Spygate.
if Russell Wilson repeats this year, ST will reach new levels of bitterness.
As long as Manning doesnt ring
With the emergence of Jamie Collins, maybe they would be okay. In the past, it was high comedy to watch Rob Ninkovich or Brandon es get shaken out of their shoes or blown by without even touching a guy like Wilson or Rodgers.^^Belichick would be much better prepared than ing John Fox, tbh
How do the Patriots generally do vs. mobile QBs?
eat them alive. BB isn't getting fooled by a gimmick offense. Also, linebackers and safeties have been specifically drafted for this, i want to see wilson monkeying around against jamie collins^^Belichick would be much better prepared than ing John Fox, tbh
How do the Patriots generally do vs. mobile QBs?
anyway, if brady wins it, which is still a big if, he's clearly the undisputed #1, if he loses, he's #2.
2 more to be the undisputed GOAT tbh
If Brady gets to 5 while putting up great numbers, I'll elevate him to GOAT. Until then he's top 5.
never liked brady but always respected him. with his longevity i'd put him #1 in my lifetime... of course Rodgers isn't done yet, but as of now, yeah.
If Brady gets his 4th ring.....he's the GOAT.
Yeah lets see those numbers.
Wonder how many more Joe would have if both he and the 49ers D knew the f'ing plays about to be run by the opponent.
Nah, its neck and neck with Joe Cool who tortured my childhood never losing in the Superdome even when the Saints had multiple top 2 defenses
Montana extricated the 49ers from some really tough situations.
And I agree, Brady can get frustrated really easily. Montana was so cold. His ability to keep his head in the game even when taunted is what Rogers seems steered towards.
As as far as who is the most fun to watch due to physical ability, it's Rogers.
Love to see the Pack win it all after the Rogers' relax comment. But I don't think they can if Rogers can't run.
Go Pats...fav. to win the SuperBowl......book it
Yeah Brady gets frustrated easily. You touch him and starts screaming for a flag, acting like such a whiny . Fortunately for him he rarely gets touched, in fact I never seen a qb get as much time in the pocket.
Rodgers reminds me the most of Montana and that's about the highest praise I can give a player. No player quite has Montana's grace under fire but Rodgers comes close. Unfortunately like Montana they both get injured a bit.
I like Manning but that's more for how he calls plays and runs an offense. Obviously he's known for the Manning Face.
I wouldn't mind seeing Packers win it all but seahawks/patriots seems like the safe bet.
I can't believe Montana lowered himself by starring in a commercial with Peyton.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
