Peyton Manning Is The Biggest Choker In The History Of The NFL

[Avante]

Peyton Manning holds how many NFL records?

How could anyone who follows the game, not get this? How in the could anyone criticize this guy?

Amazing~~~

[spurraider21]

Brady/Montana
Manning

my perception of him wasn't shifted at all this season

[Avante]

Brady/Montana
Manning

my perception of him wasn't shifted at all this season

It's about the time the Snake got his HOF bust, what took so damn long?

We see too many here that simply don't understand the game. Peyton Manning is an all time great, like you mentioned he's in the top two/three (sure we can debate that). How can anyone who understands football be critical of the great Peyton Manning?

And....how obvious can it be that Carr, RW and Newton are all going to be great NFL QB's?

[DAF86]

Brady/Montana
Manning

my perception of him wasn't shifted at all this season

I haven't watched Montana but having seen pretty much manning and brady's entire careers, there's no doubt in my mind that Manning > Brady.

Just because Tom had the chance of game mannaging to SB's earlier and more often on his career than Manning it doesn't mean he's actually better than Peyton, tbh.

[lefty]

Brady is the king of the 4th quarter comebacks tbh

[HI-FI]

This season confirmed what I already believed, that it's Montana as GOAT then Manning as 2ndGOAT. Great seeing them both in the Papa Johns commercials.

I haven't watched Montana but having seen pretty much manning and brady's entire careers, there's no doubt in my mind that Manning > Brady.

Just because Tom had the chance of game mannaging to SB's earlier and more often on his career than Manning it doesn't mean he's actually better than Peyton, tbh.

crazy to think what Manning could've been like if he had a defense like this in his prime, before getting his neck all ed up.

I don't hate Brady as much as I did, i actually respect him more for how he played against the Broncos. But even though he's evolved into a HOF franchise QB, I highly doubt he'd ever take two separate teams to the SB four times. Belichick always seems to put pretty good defenses around Brady, those defenses were badass early on but even at their worse, they were never garbage. Plus the patriots always seem simply better at adjustments and more prepared than anyone else.

[Avante]

When it comes to the playoffs.

Comp %

Montana 62.7
Brady 62.4
Manning 63.7

Career

When it comes to reg season comp %

Montana 63.2
Brady 63.6
Manning 65.5

When it comes to QB rating

Montana 92.3
Brady 96.4
Manning 96.5

Peyton Manning is an incredible QB, anyone not seeng that has no business trying to talk football.

[N0 LyF3 ScRuB]

He tried his best to choke.. Props to Peyton