I don't consider bad reasons to be real reasons and thusly dismiss them. Leonard is not clearly better than Davis because he's not healthy and may never be again. This isn't a Kyrie situation. Kawhi comes back healthy and engaged, and it's a different story from the bottom up, including how SA would play this summer.
Yeah, having a legit chance to win a championship is a terrible reason. Obviously, any team would do their due diligence, but he hasn't torn anything or had surgery and no one has said this is going to be career altering. It would be a calculated risk, but so was trading for Irving, who has had durability issues and so would be waiting on and trading for Davis, who also has.
*sigh* They aren't looking to win the trade in articles by guys like Lowe or in your esteemed evaluation on what they should get. You think Brown and Tatum are great pieces, and that might end up being true. I don't, and that might end up being true. However, it only matter if PATFO think that's whom they want. The team would be wise to do their own evaluations and not just go with guys who are hyped up, because hype doesn't win games. "Value" doesn't win games.
As if it couldn't be one in the same. Obviously, they'd do their own evaluations, but it's equally obvious that Celtics can offer the biggest haul for the next superstar who hits the trade market. Once again, you expose how little you know about the league.
They only have one really good pick coming up. The others are probably picks in the middle of the draft. Even the SAC/LAL pick can't be better than second-overall and could easily be sixth or seventh. Having Irving, aging Horford and two wings coming off leg injuries is not a no-brainer. A Kawhi who is too hurt to play for any team not in Los Angeles simply isn't worth breaking your back over, at least for Ainge, who wouldn't give up picks for Butler or George.
They have 2-3 picks that are likely to be very valuable and depth of picks beyond that. It's a no brainer because their current core isn't championship caliber or likely to be, so you take the calculated risk and force Leonard to walk away from a true contender. Butler/George aren't in Leonard's class.
Yes, I'm equating guys who scored very well in the Celtics' offense before to guys scoring well in it now. That the current guys aren't scoring as well as their predecessors would suggest they aren't nearly as slam-dunk as they're reported as being to anyone who isn't trying to prop up their argument. You're talking about role-players as if they're established stars while also pointing out that the Celtics don't even have a second banana. Just not a good position to defend.
Now you're basing value off of ppg and doing so without context. Thomas averaged 3-4 more mpg and had a usage rate 13-15% higher than Tatum/Brown and while Bradley's usage rate was similar to Tatum/Brown, he was doing so in similar mpg to Thomas. I'm saying, there's a baseline to Tatum/Brown already, that there isn't to most of the other prospects you named. You trade a player the magnitude of Leonard, unless it's a prospect thought to be can't miss, you're going to want some certainty.
That's the biggest selling point to some stars, especially those who are looking to join other teams. It's not necessarily what Kawhi wants. Leonard apparently doesn't want to recruit any other players, yet you think those other players are going to be what makes him re-sign. It's not a consistent argument either. If Kawhi is willing/desiring to leave SA, it's not because he can't win there. He's gotten closer with SA than most of his peers have gotten other places (already has his ring and has only missed the third round twice in his career). He'd be leaving SA to go home, and home is home whether you have a Robin there or not.
I didn't say Leonard would necessarily re-sign, I said you make him walk away from about as appealing a situation as you can create, if you're Celtics. Also, if he's even remotely interested in contending, he needs other superstars/stars to win, so I'd imagine having that would hold appeal, as well as not having to play recruiter. He hasn't had a chance to win with Spurs since becoming a superstar and barring a Walker trade, won't anytime soon either.