big Ghaz hit it on the head
Aaron Rodgers consistently will complete passes that no other QB can replicate. Just crazy talented in terms of accuracy from all points on the field. In the NBA, there's always the debate of "who do you want taking the last shot?". If there was an NFL equivalent (i.e. you have one pass to the endzone to win the game from ____ yards away, who do you choose?), I'd go with Rodgers
but something is missing when it comes to the GOAT talk tbh and i don't watch enough football to know what it is. Outside of the great three-year stretch of 2010-2012, I don't see many big wins especially since that time frame. I know they beat the Patriots in 2014, but I can't think of any others since that timeframe. The only playoff success they've had was beating the GarrettBot a few times in the playoffs, which is about as difficult as tying your own shoe.
Other than that, they will consistently lose games against playoff teams and either beat the drum off of crappy ones or have some miraculous comeback, which overshadows the fact that their opponent was subpar in the first place
Obviously he's not had the best teams/coaching around him, but I don't see that as an excuse when debating whether or not he's the GOAT. Peyton Manning had plenty of seasons where he didn't have talent around him, but still made the Colts annual contenders