He's a hard player for me to rate all time tbh. On one hand he's obviously an amazing talent with and led the greatest comeback in NBA history by beating the Warriors after being down 3-1. His stats are all time great and he will probably finish top 10 in points and assists and maybe rebounds? Idk about the rebounds part. He will play in the most post season games of all time. He is like a 16 time all star, 14 all NBA, 4 time MVP and 3 time Finals MVP, and has 9 finals on his resume.
Buuut there's just a part of me that is disappointed in him on th biggest stage. He should have more/or the very least equal amount of rings than Shaq. He's had better teammates than Duncan and yet has less rings than him. He has so much drama with him that it makes the season harder than it needs to be. He isn't really a leader except for 3 years on the Cavs when he came back. He's top 10 all time, probably top 5 but I would pick Duncan over Lebron to start a franchise. I would choose Bird, Magic, Jordan, Kareem, and Shaq as well over him. So to start a franchise I would pick him 7th.