Duncan is obviously better than Amare individually...BUT, not when he has Shaq at his side. Shaq takes up so much attention, Amare is free to do his thing...Amare will get his 25-30 points a night. Duncan will get about 20.
Ah, I know, the Manu is better than anybody but I'm saying defense wise, Raja will do a good job on him. Just like Bowen will do a good job on Hill but Hill doesn't need to do much so Bowen's talents are wasted. I'm not sure how effective Bowen is on Nash since he's a scorer and a break-down passer. I think if Bowen guards Nash, Duncan, Fabio and KT are going to be in foul trouble.
Nash can't defend Tony but Tony can't defend Nash either. Tony's great in the paint but he has Shaq and Amare waiting for him in the paint. Nash doesn't look to score on his penetration...he tries to draw Duncan or Oberto for an easy shot by Shaq or Amare.
The thing with Nash is he breaks down the interior defense. With Shaq and Amare the recipients, Timmy, Oberto and KT are going to have a long night.
It's going to be a pound for pound equal matchup in my opinion...probably the most even of any possible playoff matchup.