Nobody, and I mean NOBODY deserved it over him, because the MVP means the most VALUABLE ot his team, and nobody compares to Nash in that category. Now you wanna say best player in the league that year, then Kobe would have about 7 awards, but that's not what the award is. And now most people around the country think he should have gotten his third, as Dirk's numbers were down, but he was valuable to leading his team to 67 wins, so he got the award, but again, Kobe was far and away the best player.