Page 6 of 10 FirstFirst ... 2345678910 LastLast
Results 126 to 150 of 248
  1. #126
    ATRAIN is gay peewee's lovechild's Avatar
    Location
    San Antonio
    Post Count
    17,827
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    College
    Notre Dame Fighting Irish
    there's no way Horn could have known for sure how these two would react to an old man with a shotgun.
    There's no way he could have been sure that his house wasn't next and that they didn't have weapons of their own.

    I don't own any weapons, and I'm all for gun control. But, even I can see that he didn't do anything wrong. Was he being preemptive? Maybe. But, I would rather be preemptive than to be a victim. There's no way in that I'm just going to sit back and become a potential victim.

    Isn't that how France got invaded by the Nazis in WWII? Let's ignore this Adolf Hitler guy invading Austria, Hungary, and Poland. If we just keep quiet and ignore this Hitler fellow he'll just leave us be . . . . ohhh, looks like that was a bad idea. We'll just wait for the Americans to bail us out.

  2. #127
    go balls deep for jesus Kermit's Avatar
    Post Count
    4,720
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    College
    Texas Longhorns
    Isn't that how France got invaded by the Nazis in WWII? Let's ignore this Adolf Hitler guy invading Austria, Hungary, and Poland. If we just keep quiet and ignore this Hitler fellow he'll just leave us be . . . . ohhh, looks like that was a bad idea. We'll just wait for the Americans to bail us out.


    Just when this couldn't get any more inane, someone brings out the Hitler invading France argument. God damn, people. I know everyone has their own beliefs, but let us not venture into Re ville, pop. 1.

    Here's Ol' Horn's reaction to the shooting, just in case anyone cares.

    http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/...n/5866865.html

    By RUTH RENDON
    Copyright 2008 Houston Chronicle


    WHAT HORN SAID

    On the 12-gauge shotgun Horn retrieved from his car: "The gun saved my life. It took two lives but it saved mine. How do you evaluate that? Yes, it's awful but it saved my life"

    Contrary to what can be heard on the 911 tape, Horn insists his plan was to go outside to see if he could get a better description to give police: "My plan was very simple. Nothing was going to get me out that door without a plan. As far as shooting a shotgun goes, I knew I wasn't going to shoot anybody. There was no danger to any of the bad guys or police officers"

    His attorney and friend, Tom Lambright , was the first to tell him he had been cleared: "It felt like a huge weight had just been removed from me. I immediately called my daughter at work. She squealed. She was just ecstatic. There was a lot of emotion. It was a huge relief"

    For seven months, Horn thought he would be indicted largely on account of the 911 conversation: "How was I ever going to try to explain that? The manner in which I talked was just not me"

    Horn became even more frightened when he lost sight of the alleged burglars: "It was bad enough when I was upstairs and looking at them. But I could see them. When they disappeared and I went downstairs, the fear was magnified tenfold because now I can't see them and they could come into my house. There is the unknown that was terrifying. I thought it was bad but it got worse"

    On looking back at the life he had before the shootings: "I want it back so bad. I'm scared I won't get it back. I hope this is the beginning of better times for me"
    The voice of Joe Horn on the infamous 911 tape, the one telling police he wasn't going to let the men burglarizing his neighbors' house get away, that he was "gonna shoot" them, is not the voice of the real Joe Horn, he told the Houston Chronicle on Tuesday.

    Nor is the man who grabbed his shotgun, left his house against a 911 operator's orders, pumped a s into the chamber and shot the men down after shouting "move, you're dead," the real Joe Horn.

    The real Joe Horn, he insisted in an exclusive interview the day after he was cleared by a Harris County grand jury in the deaths of Diego Ortiz and Hernando Riascos Torres, is just a boring retired engineer.

    And a 61-year-old Pasadena grandfather who, energized by fear that afternoon last Nov. 14, made a decision that has haunted him since, a decision he would take back if he could.

    "I would never advocate anyone doing what I did," Horn said from his attorney's west Houston home. "We are not geared for that."

    Gunning down the two unemployed illegal immigrants from Colombia rocketed Horn from his suburban obscurity into a deeply divided vortex of public scrutiny. He has been hailed on the one side as a hero, as a neighbor anyone would want; and on the other as nothing more than a vigilante taking the law into his own hands.

    In a calm, soft voice, Horn said Tuesday he was neither — not a man worthy of praise, nor one who merits scorn.

    "I know what a hero is, and that's not me," he said. "I'm a human being that was in a situation that I'd never been in before, and I didn't want to die."


    'You lose track of time'
    Horn's account of the events leading up to the shootings differs sharply in parts with what can be heard on the tape of the call he made to 911 shortly after seeing the men allegedly breaking into his neighbors' house.

    He said he was upstairs in his gameroom, tinkering with a computer, when the quiet of the Village Grove East subdivision was shattered by the sound of breaking glass. He instinctively blamed the family cat, Horn said, before realizing that the noise had come from outside.

    He looked out the window and saw two men, both dressed in dark green T-shirts, blue jeans and tennis shoes, breaking into his neighbors' home through a block glass window.

    He called 911 on his cell phone.

    He said he began to feel scared. He didn't know who the men were, nor if his neighbors were home and were in danger. Was his home the next target?

    He went to his car to get a 12-gauge shotgun he kept in a leather case on the floorboard.

    "All I was thinking was, 'Oh my God,' " he said. "You lose track of time. You don't ever think about that. You start thinking about all kinds of things. ... I was feeling helpless."

    From his upstairs window, Horn said he saw the men leave his neighbors' home and walk around the back of the house where he couldn't see them.

    While still on the phone with the 911 dispatcher, he said he went downstairs with the goal of getting a description of the men to give police.

    But, according to the transcript, he provided the dispatcher a far different motive:

    Operator: Mr. Horn, do not go out the house.

    Horn: I'm sorry. This ain't right, buddy.

    Operator: You're going to get yourself shot if you go outside that house with that gun. I don't care what you think. Stay in the house.

    Horn: You wanna make a bet? I'm gonna kill 'em.

    As he was going downstairs, Horn said the fear and adrenaline rush was intense.

    "I'm thinking if they go out the front door, I can't see them at all," he said. His plan was to look out the front door window to get a better view of his neighbor's house. Seeing nothing, he ventured outside.

    He said he took one step off his front porch and saw nothing. "I felt great. I was so relieved that I didn't see anything. I thought, 'It's over with.' "

    Then he saw the men come around the corner and head into his front yard. Horn had his cell phone in his front shirt pocket while he handled the shotgun.


    'No fear in their eyes'

    "It went from 'I'm glad it's all over' to instant fear," he said.

    He shouted the words he now regrets: "Move, you're dead." The men — about 10 feet and 13 feet from him — stopped immediately. They looked at one another and said nothing.

    "There was no fear in their eyes," Horn said.

    One of the men, believed to be Torres, started to charge him, Horn said. He fired.

    "There was no time to aim," Horn said. "To this day, I still don't know where I shot."

    Horn said he turned slightly to the right and fired toward the second man, Ortiz, who ran at a fast pace back in the direction of his neighbor's house. Torres remained in his yard and was walking back toward Horn. He fired a third shot.

    Horn didn't think his shots struck either man.

    "I went inside because the guy (Ortiz) disappeared," he said. "I thought he was behind the house. ... I was desperate for the police to get there."

    A police car screeched to a halt in front of his house. An officer drew his gun and ordered him "on the ground."

    Horn, who still had his cell phone to his ear, dropped face-first and was handcuffed.

    He was eventually allowed to sit up and saw one of the men across the street, lying prone. "I thought I scared him enough to fall to the ground."

    It wasn't until he overheard one officer tell another that "there were two burglars and this man just killed them" that he realized both men were dead.

    The moment was surreal.

    "It was like nothing I've ever felt," Horn said. "It was like it wasn't really happening. Just numb."

    [email protected]
    Last edited by Kermit; 07-02-2008 at 10:34 AM.

  3. #128
    I Got Hops Extra Stout's Avatar
    Location
    Dublin
    Post Count
    13,614
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    I doubt that Horn got off because the grand jury believed he really was in fear for his life. He put himself in harm's way. The "castle" defense does not apply because there was no immediate threat to his person from the burglars.

    However, there is a clause in that "castle" law that allows for the use of deadly force to prevent burglars from absconding with stolen property. The law says nothing regarding whose stolen property that is. Likely, it was this particular clause that allowed Mr. Horn to avoid prosecution.

    I am not surprised that most Texans support what Mr. Horn did. We tend to think that when a person commits a criminal act, his life is forfeit, unless we are connected to that person. We also are very much into vengeance and vigilantism. The background of the burglars also tends to devalue their lives in the eyes of many. I allege that had it been a couple of teenagers from the neighborhood who were robbing houses and got themselves killed, public opinion would be substantially different.

    In my view, ideally the killing of other people should be only an act of last resort.

  4. #129
    Cinnamon Girl mrsmaalox's Avatar
    Name
    Yvonne
    Location
    San Antonio, Texas
    Post Count
    17,464
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    I hardly ever agree with TPark, but I'm with him on this one.

    For anyone of you to side with the burglars is just pure stupidity. If those two dumbasses would've stayed at home, they wouldn't be dead right now.

    I'm very pro gun control, but I'm also for protecting yourself and your property if you feel threatned. It doesn't matter that they were robbing Horn's neighbor. Who is to say that they weren't going to move on to Horn's house after they swept through his neighbor's house. None of you can make an assured statment that they wouldn't have gone into Horn's house after they finished with his neighbor's house.

    It's extremely plausible that Horn felt threatned. And, I believe that he did the right thing. It's not his fault that those two guys decided to committ a crime.
    I'm not going to argue what the law says or doesn't say, but come on. Who's to say the mailman walking down my street is not going to go postal and shoot the the place up? Should I shoot him just to be sure?! Some folks are just oversimplifying the whole thing to make their point against their percieved "vigilantism". It was dark, Horn knew they were doing something bad, and he felt threatened. That's all there is to it.

  5. #130
    I Got Hops Extra Stout's Avatar
    Location
    Dublin
    Post Count
    13,614
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    Isn't that how France got invaded by the Nazis in WWII? Let's ignore this Adolf Hitler guy invading Austria, Hungary, and Poland. If we just keep quiet and ignore this Hitler fellow he'll just leave us be . . . . ohhh, looks like that was a bad idea. We'll just wait for the Americans to bail us out.
    You know this means you automatically lose the thread, right?

  6. #131
    Cinnamon Girl mrsmaalox's Avatar
    Name
    Yvonne
    Location
    San Antonio, Texas
    Post Count
    17,464
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    You know this means you automatically lose the thread, right?
    That's just one reason!! The other one is the blatent misunderstanding of CF's "blind eye" statement!!

  7. #132
    ATRAIN is gay peewee's lovechild's Avatar
    Location
    San Antonio
    Post Count
    17,827
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    College
    Notre Dame Fighting Irish
    You know this means you automatically lose the thread, right?
    Yea, but I felt like hamming it up.

  8. #133
    ATRAIN is gay peewee's lovechild's Avatar
    Location
    San Antonio
    Post Count
    17,827
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    College
    Notre Dame Fighting Irish
    That's just one reason!! The other one is the blatent misunderstanding of CF's "blind eye" statement!!
    Not at all.

  9. #134
    Get Refuel! FromWayDowntown's Avatar
    Post Count
    19,921
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    College
    Columbia Lions
    I doubt that Horn got off because the grand jury believed he really was in fear for his life. He put himself in harm's way. The "castle" defense does not apply because there was no immediate threat to his person from the burglars.

    However, there is a clause in that "castle" law that allows for the use of deadly force to prevent burglars from absconding with stolen property. The law says nothing regarding whose stolen property that is. Likely, it was this particular clause that allowed Mr. Horn to avoid prosecution.
    I agree with this. I think there is an absurdity to a construction of the castle doctrine that allows a person to shoot someone who is burglarizing (or committing other crimes) with respect to another's property -- if I'm driving down a street in a town that I don't live in and see two guys who appear to be running away from a home with stereos in their hand, am I immediately justified in stopping my car, grabbing my gun, and shooting them dead? I think at that point, the exception basically swallows the rule and comes relatively close to justifying a wide array of homicides. It makes sense to me that the doctrine will allow me to protect my home from an invader; it doesn't make sense to me that the doctrine essentially deputizes me.

    In my view, ideally the killing of other people should be only an act of last resort.
    Amen to that.

  10. #135
    Seeking the quiet mind desflood's Avatar
    Location
    MI
    Post Count
    5,054
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    I'm not going to argue what the law says or doesn't say, but come on. Who's to say the mailman walking down my street is not going to go postal and shoot the the place up? Should I shoot him just to be sure?
    The difference is that the mailman is not already committing a potentially violent illegal act, which a burglar most definitely is.

  11. #136
    Che cazzo stai dicendo? DisgruntledLionFan#54,927's Avatar
    Post Count
    7,801
    NBA Team
    Detroit Pistons
    Operator: You're going to get yourself shot if you go outside that house with that gun. I don't care what you think. Stay in the house.

    Horn: You wanna make a bet? I'm gonna kill 'em.
    Pretty cut and dry, IMO.

  12. #137
    Orange Whip? Orange Whip? Viva Las Espuelas's Avatar
    Name
    5 letters long
    Post Count
    19,497
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    f I'm driving down a street in a town that I don't live in and see two guys who appear to be running away from a home with stereos in their hand, am I immediately justified in stopping my car,
    apples and oranges..
    did this guy's house have the ability to speed up out of harms way? no. what you're trying to parallel this to isn't even in the same ballpark. i feel if you stop you put yourself in harms way. i believe in self defense and if it comes to that then shoot first and ask questions later.
    you people, out of the state of texas i'm assuming, are something else trying to paint this guy as some evil guy.

  13. #138
    Get Refuel! FromWayDowntown's Avatar
    Post Count
    19,921
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    College
    Columbia Lions
    apples and oranges..
    did this guy's house have the ability to speed up out of harms way? no. what you're trying to parallel this to isn't even in the same ballpark. i feel if you stop you put yourself in harms way. i believe in self defense and if it comes to that then shoot first and ask questions later.
    you people, out of the state of texas i'm assuming, are something else trying to paint this guy as some evil guy.
    Okay, so I'm walking down a street in a city I don't live in and see this happen -- can I justifiably pull my gun and start shooting? I no longer have the option of just speeding up and driving away, after all.

    Oh, and I live in San Antonio by the way.

  14. #139
    Orange Whip? Orange Whip? Viva Las Espuelas's Avatar
    Name
    5 letters long
    Post Count
    19,497
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    Okay, so I'm walking down a street in a city I don't live in and see this happen -- can I justifiably pull my gun and start shooting? I no longer have the option of just speeding up and driving away, after all.

    Oh, and I live in San Antonio by the way.
    i guess i need to spell it out for you. in both cases you are mobile. be it old person speed or ludicrous speed. you can move your ass on out of there. his house is not mobile.

  15. #140
    Get Refuel! FromWayDowntown's Avatar
    Post Count
    19,921
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    College
    Columbia Lions
    i guess i need to spell it out for you. in both cases you are mobile. be it old person speed or ludicrous speed. you can move your ass on out of there. his house is not mobile.
    Okay, so why is the shooter in this case any different from me in that example? He's mobile, isn't he? He can get away from the danger, can't he?

    Is he different from me in that example only because there's some hypothetical chance that the burglars might target his home next? Then take my example again, only this time I'm walking down my street (but several houses away from my own) and I see two guys who appear to be absconding with burglarized property and running in a direction that is opposite my home, am I immediately justified in shooting to kill?

  16. #141
    Orange Whip? Orange Whip? Viva Las Espuelas's Avatar
    Name
    5 letters long
    Post Count
    19,497
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    Okay, so why is the shooter in this case any different from me in that example? He's mobile, isn't he? He can get away from the danger, can't he?

    Is he different from me in that example only because there's some hypothetical chance that the burglars might target his home next? Then take my example again, only this time I'm walking down my street (but several houses away from my own) and I see two guys who appear to be absconding with burglarized property and running in a direction that is opposite my home, am I immediately justified in shooting to kill?
    youre grasping now, chump III. this guy was in his home they knew where he lives. any example you give they are mobile and they wouldn't have a clue where you live. you can move your ass out of the whole situation.
    NEXT!

  17. #142
    Get Refuel! FromWayDowntown's Avatar
    Post Count
    19,921
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    College
    Columbia Lions
    youre grasping now, chump III. this guy was in his home they knew where he lives. any example you give they are mobile and they wouldn't have a clue where you live. you can move your ass out of the whole situation.
    NEXT!
    I'm not grasping at anything -- I'm mostly interested in having someone explain to me where the castle doctrine stops if it can be used as a justification for shooting those who are robbing my neighbor's house. Assessing how the doctrine would apply in various hypothetical situations is a good way to test that.

    If you're not interested in actually discussing that question -- and I'll take it from your aspersions about my intelligence that you aren't really interested in it -- I'll be happy to leave the question out there for others to answer.

    I really do want to know just how far the doctrine extends. It seems I can protect my neighbor's house, but what about the guy on the next street over? Or how about the woman who lives at the other end of the street? Or maybe the guy who lives in the apartment complex next to mine?

  18. #143
    ATRAIN is gay peewee's lovechild's Avatar
    Location
    San Antonio
    Post Count
    17,827
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    College
    Notre Dame Fighting Irish
    Bottom line . . . if you don't want to get shot, and possibly killed, don't go robbing houses.

    It really is that simple.

    If you come anywhere near my house, if I had one, I would shoot your ass dead, if I had a shotgun.

  19. #144
    ATRAIN is gay peewee's lovechild's Avatar
    Location
    San Antonio
    Post Count
    17,827
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    College
    Notre Dame Fighting Irish
    And, if I shoot you dead because you were robbing my home, or because you were robbing my neighbor's house and I felt threatened that you might rob mine, I don't want your friends and family raising their fists in the air trying to make it a civil rights issue.

  20. #145
    I Got Hops Extra Stout's Avatar
    Location
    Dublin
    Post Count
    13,614
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    If you come anywhere near my house, if I had one, I would shoot your ass dead, if I had a shotgun.

  21. #146
    Believe. Ronaldo McDonald's Avatar
    Location
    Texas, Ubiquitous States of America
    Post Count
    1,818
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    No one deserves to die for robbing a house. The guy who shot should have just shot him the leg. ing moron. I bet guy who shot is probably some white trash interbred re ed Texan who thinks he's John Wayne.

  22. #147
    I Got Hops Extra Stout's Avatar
    Location
    Dublin
    Post Count
    13,614
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    If you come near the freeway overpass where I sleep, I'll throw my empty bottles at you.

  23. #148
    ATRAIN is gay peewee's lovechild's Avatar
    Location
    San Antonio
    Post Count
    17,827
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    College
    Notre Dame Fighting Irish
    I don't have a house and I don't own a weapon. But, that doesn't change the fact that I support people's right to defend themselves.

  24. #149
    ATRAIN is gay peewee's lovechild's Avatar
    Location
    San Antonio
    Post Count
    17,827
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    College
    Notre Dame Fighting Irish
    No one deserves to die for robbing a house. The guy who shot should have just shot him the leg. ing moron. I bet guy who shot is probably some white trash interbred re ed Texan who thinks he's John Wayne.
    If you come anywhere near my house and I percieve you as a threat, you sure as deserve to die.

    And, I'm not inbred or white.

  25. #150
    ATRAIN is gay peewee's lovechild's Avatar
    Location
    San Antonio
    Post Count
    17,827
    NBA Team
    San Antonio Spurs
    College
    Notre Dame Fighting Irish
    If you come near the freeway overpass where I sleep, I'll throw my empty bottles at you.
    Hahaha. That's funny.

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •