You know I wouldn't be opposed to a shorter, less in-depth version of grades with something like the following format -
Player X <grade>
The good: (bullet points)
The bad: (bullet points)
Maybe a one or two sentence summary
I say this because timvp tends to engage in the discussion after the grades anyway.
The advantages of having a shorter, less in-depth version of grades are two-fold:
1) I'm sure it'll be easier on timvp ( , he's basically having to write the equivalent of an entire article right after the game. It's not easy)
and
2) We'll get a nice postgame discussion going immediately after the game when thoughts are still fresh.
Don't get me wrong, I love the comprehensive takes, but I certainly wouldn't mind if we saw a shorter version in the future.