Reply With Quote
Rivers & Luck being higher on the list than Romo
Tier 1: Elite
1 - Aaron Rogers
2 - Ben Roethlisberger
3 - Tom Brady
4 - Philip Rivers
5 - Andrew Luck
6 - Tony Romo
7 - Matt Ryan
8 - Drew Brees
9 - Russell Wilson
Tier 2: "Next level QB's" (above average)
10 - Carson Palmer
11 - Cam Newton
12 - Peyton Manning
13 - Matthew Stafford
14 - Joe Flacco
15 - Ryan Tannehill
16 - Sam Bradford
17 - Eli Manning
18 - Alex Smith
19 - Teddy Bridgewater
20 - Colin Kaepernick
Tier 3: "Stuck in the middle" (average/inconsistent)
21 - Jay Cutler
22 - Andy Dalton
23 - Nick Foles
24 - Marcus Mariota
25 - Blake Bortles
26 - Tyrod Taylor
Tier 4: "Hot Seat"
27 - Kirk Cousins
28 - Ryan Fitzpatrick
29 - Jameis Winston
30 - Derek Carr
31 - Jonny Manziel
32 - Brian Hoyer
Alex Smith gets zero respect
I'll give you Luck, but Rivers is the most accurate passer in the game.
what a re ed list..
Mariota is in the 3rd tier?
Too high: Big Rape, Rivers, Ryan, Struggle, , Johnny Leaf
Too low: Palmer, Flacco, Tannehill
He's the textbook definition of an average game manager, and he s the bed in the playoffs. Basically the 2015 version of Neil O'Donnell.Alex Smith gets zero respect
Nine is too many elite QBs.
You try making a somewhat intelligent comment (Rivers > Romo), then completely lose all credibility with your second commentAlex Smith gets zero respect
If the Giants win Sunday it's pretty unlikely that Romo's on the first tier of that list, whether he deserves to be or not.
how the is Rapistburger no.2? maybe i'm missing something. Rodgers is easily no.1. If Brady (or whomever they shuffle into QB) has Ernie Adams telling them what the D is doing every down then I guess no. 2 or 3 is fair.
Romo has been the most underrated bean3r in quite sometime. I'd take him over most of the QBs.
cosigned.Alex Smith gets zero respect
Guys, it's not that hard to see why they'd rank Ben so high. He was the leading passer in the NFL last year, breaking several franchise records along the way, including back to back 500 yard games.
Furthermore, go yourselves.
Lol @ Bridgewater
Rosenthal has been on teddy's nutsack for a long time. I disregard anything he says
Is there any specific reason bortles is a tier ahead of Carr
well, you've got to give him the edge since he doesn't play for the raiders..Rosenthal has been on teddy's nutsack for a long time. I disregard anything he says
Is there any specific reason bortles is a tier ahead of Carr
Are the jags that much better?
Its one thing to rank him higher (which I'd assume most disagree with) but to have him in another tier? Cmon
and lol @ "hot seat" tag.. what was the guy smoking tbhAre the jags that much better?
Its one thing to rank him higher (which I'd assume most disagree with) but to have him in another tier? Cmon
it's romo's to lose and not even close tbh
romo is not an elite qb btw, never been never will.. it's nice to see him improve though, but that is to be expected given the offensive line.
elite dont include deflating balls tbh
what language is that?
Mariota is in the 3rd tier?
What do you consider "Elite".
2 timer at 17?
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
