Reply With Quote
Top 5?
He would be cemented in the top 3 and you would have to be very biased to believe otherwise, tbh..
Would a championship against the historic GSW team cement Lebron's legacy as a Top 5 player of all time?
Top 5?
He would be cemented in the top 3 and you would have to be very biased to believe otherwise, tbh..
He's secure a spot as one of the top 5 current players in the East.
glurgh garghhhh glurghhhlleleeeeTop 5?
He would be cemented in the top 3 and you would have to be very biased to believe otherwise, tbh..
Thats sound of his in your mouth I hear everytime you post about Lebron got. For the record, hope he does win.
So what happens if he doesn't?Top 5?
He would be cemented in the top 3 and you would have to be very biased to believe otherwise, tbh..
Top 5?
He is in the convo absolutely.
With a 3rd ring he solidifies GOAT SF status (not sure how even 80's fans like myself can argue otherwiseand I already have bumped Bird to my all time 2nd team)
Kareem and MJ are definitely ahead of him.
But he has a case over Duncan, Magic Bird etc.Unless you count rings which for me matter a bunch ...(I dont make that team accomplishment cop out) ...but with 3 rings in in in 7 tries along with the historic regular season numbers, longevity and overall health hard to say he is not top 5 even at only 3 rings to duncan or Magic's 5 ...
Believe me, I dont want him to pass Magic and I still would rather have the 5 rings ...
but Lebron's carer is like cross between peak Bird with Karl Malone type health and longevity (so far)
That is crazy.
All that being said this nicca needs to win another ring.
Could be tough. The knock on Lebron has always been his individual brilliance but the less than expected team performance in the playoffs. A lot of it is due to him having teams that aren't really build as championships teams.
As an individual player, Lebron really has an argument as being GOAT as his combination of physical dominance, intelligence, and skills is really unmatched by anyone. That said, his teams are not ideal to win championships, at least in part, due to his ghost-GMing/coaching, and he really brought a lot of that himself. Like I said before, he's to player what Larry Brown is to coaches, brilliant, and unquestionably one of the greatest at what they are supposed to do. Unfortunately, both of them then to step out of their lane and lead to their respective teams under-performing.
If you define top player as individual brilliance, he's already top 5, likely top 3. If you define top player as having the best career, he is barely top 10. If you define top player as ease of building a championship around, he is somewhere between 5 and 10, I'd probably settle at around 8 or 9.
no
Some great points, Amb. Love your different criteria perspectives.
That being said not only is his GM a en suspect ,Isnt the type of player he is ...force teams to be constructed the way the Cavs are now?
His best success has come with a team built with a all-star wing man and defensive help and spot up shooters. As great as he is his suspect 3 point shooting forces the teams he is on to seek out the Channing Frye's and Mike Millers and forces them to tolerate the JR smith types and Boobie Gibson types because he needs shooters to be successful.
All that being said if you are just talking combo of skill, athleticism size and speed honestly LeBron crushes even Jordan from a natural ability and talent perspective ... LeBron is the most naturaly gifted NBA player I have ever seen play.
Career wise as many have said he needs more rings and a bit more continued greatness. But peak Level Lebron is up there in the GOAT convo ...
One could still argue for a 6-10 placement due to a poor Finals record.
No way u believe that...LBJ has had the easiest road to the finals in NBA history tbh..if he was in the WCF he wouldnt make it to the finals and you know it. Dude is a physical GOAT but mentally not even in the top 500 players ever.Top 5?
He would be cemented in the top 3 and you would have to be very biased to believe otherwise, tbh..
He's cleaned up his mental act lately. Last year was the classiest loss ever since Timmy Duncan
No, what'll keep him out of the top 5 is his coach killing and gm skills. Imagine Bird the player being also a gm who trades away Kawhi at the same time. That's LeBron, who trades away Wiggins and runs a cancerous patronage system. That's why Duncan gets overrated, it's the extreme classiness
check your main.
Name a top-5-worthy player who came into a worse situation than LeBron did? The Cavaliers were dead when he got here- they were an embarrassment on the floor and in the front office, a total afterthought in the city- nobody gave a - and in probably the worst market in the NBA (with the arguable exception of Minnesota.) You can't compare that to Magic going to the Lakers, Bird to the Celtics, even MJ to the Bulls (at least Chicago is a big market and they did draft Pippen and Grant when MJ was still a young player.)
It would have been tough for a lot of top guys to win a le in Cleveland in those years. Of contemporary guys, I think Duncan definitely could've won les here, but Wade? Kobe? Dirk? Would've been tough for them, too.
His legacy is already cemented.
If somebody said person X was "The Lebron James of finance" or "The Lebron James of Cricket", what would that mean?
If somebody said he's "the Tim Duncan of Cricket", what would that mean?
Meaning is in the eye of the beholder. It would mean something very different to, say, an intelligent fan vs. a casual.
the happiest moment in Lebron james fanboys lives
The thing that really kills me is that Lebron is actually pretty easy to build around. You put a team with 2 or 3 3&D guys, a rim protector/rebounder type (not really that important as Lebron can even be that in a small ball lineup), and "not horrible" bench, and it's a championship contending team.
But due to his at ude, you have to have strong minded GMs and coaches (Riley) to put him in his place, and make him fall in line, you have to have closers around him like Ray Allen and Wade to bail him out. His diva at ude, though not absolutely terrible, didn't help him win more championships.
He really never found his Phil Jackson. Jordan was like that, or worse prior to Phil. Actually, his battles with Krause was worse than anything Lebron did with his coaches/GMs, but Phil kept Jordan in line, and Jordan was smart enough not to let his personal agenda get in the way of winning championships.
But most the GOATS had this ego. Kareem forced his way out of Milwaukee, Magic got a coach fired (though Magic was really in the right), Jordan feuded with Krause throughout and froze out Kukoc. Russell, Duncan and Bird didn't really let their pride get in their way. The respect the work done by coaches and management, and were fortunate enough to land on teams with strong management (or they will end up like KG).
Kareem and Jordan went to pretty bad teams.
No question Lebron's first stint on Cleveland is on management. They just rolled out carts and carts of horrible players and coaches. I mean, Mike Brown? Boobie Gibson? Mo Williams? Those were horrible. I don't even fault his move to Miami as it really was a right move career-wise. People have issues about the press conference and the insane level of arrogance, but really, if I am that good, I'd probably be ten times worse. What really got me was how he left Miami and dictated the trades of Wiggins and then having Blatt fired. Blatt really isn't a bad coach, he needed some refinement in his coaching styles but he also needed to have a few seasons to work on the team. Blatt was thrown under the bus hard.
As for Duncan winning a le in Cleveland in the first stint? I doubt it. I don't think anybody could have done it if Lebron couldn't do it. With the current lineup? I can see a prime Duncan winning a le, or come close to it under the old rules. None of the other guys would even come close.
If somebody said person X was "da_suns_fan in life", what would that mean?
i hope he wins. Its going to be extremely difficult, and i hope he will pull through, winning this series will have so much value.
rooting for the cavs brah !
Hope Cleveland can celebrate a le this year, would be great for the city
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
